Use AutoInsureSavings to find the best rates and save money today.
Compare all car insurance companies at once.
Looking for a new or used Tesla Model S? And wondering how much it costs to insure by year? We researched average annual insurance costs for each model year and have compiled the results for you below.
Average full coverage auto insurance premium: $205/month
Most affordable companies: Nationwide ($161/month) & Progressive ($172/month)
Model S car insurance cost vs. average rate: $432 more expensive than the average vehicle
Explore the pricing information below to find how much it will cost you to insure your Tesla Model S by model year and auto insurer.
California car insurance - $3,620 per year
Florida car insurance - $3,518 per year
New York car insurance - $3,917 per year
Arizona - $2,632 per year
Texas - $2,955 per year
Select the year of your car
Cheapest Insurance Companies | Average Annual Cost |
---|---|
Tesla | $1,825 |
Nationwide | $1,938 |
Progressive | $2,065 |
The Cincinnati | $2,158 |
State Farm | $2,160 |
Erie | $2,230 |
Liberty Mutual | $2,313 |
GEICO | $2,650 |
Texas Farm Bureau | $2,748 |
American Family | $2,896 |
Tennessee Farmers | $3,121 |
Mercury | $3,250 |
Allstate | $3,348 |
Travelers | $3,405 |
Country Financial | $3,519 |
Amica | $3,547 |
Kentucky Farm Bureau | $3,648 |
The Hanover | $3,728 |
MetLife | $4,015 |
21st Century | $4,289 |
Allied | $4,452 |
Cheapest Insurance Companies | Average Annual Cost |
---|---|
Tesla | $1,765 |
Nationwide | $1,890 |
Progressive | $1,964 |
State Farm | $2,043 |
Erie | $2,168 |
Liberty Mutual | $2,259 |
GEICO | $2,547 |
Texas Farm Bureau | $2,699 |
American Family | $2,843 |
Tennessee Farmers | $3,025 |
Mercury | $3,147 |
Allstate | $3,265 |
Travelers | $3,315 |
Country Financial | $3,490 |
Kentucky Farm Bureau | $3,547 |
The Hanover | $4,002 |
21st Century | $4,168 |
Cheapest Insurance Companies | Average Annual Cost |
---|---|
American Family | $1,733 |
Erie | $1,804 |
Cincinnati Insurance | $1,879 |
Nationwide | $2,027 |
USAA | $2,203 |
Country | $2,352 |
State Farm | $2,384 |
Progressive | $2,578 |
Liberty Mutual | $3,154 |
MetLife | $3,714 |
GEICO | $4,022 |
Cheapest Insurance Companies | Average Annual Cost |
---|---|
Erie | $1,398 |
USAA | $1,953 |
Nationwide | $1,963 |
Country | $2,291 |
Progressive | $2,400 |
State Farm | $2,651 |
American Family | $3,239 |
Liberty Mutual | $3,309 |
GEICO | $3,333 |
MetLife | $3,596 |
AAA | $4,343 |
Cheapest Insurance Companies | Average Annual Cost |
---|---|
Country | $837 |
Cincinnati Insurance | $872 |
Erie | $875 |
Allmerica | $886 |
Mercury | $888 |
Acuity | $912 |
Vermont Mutual | $931 |
Plymouth Rock Insurance | $934 |
USAA | $999 |
Farmers | $1,026 |
MetLife | $1,037 |
Oklahoma Farmers Union | $1,088 |
Cheapest Insurance Companies | Average Annual Cost |
---|---|
Cincinnati Insurance | $729 |
Texas Farm Bureau | $785 |
Oklahoma Farmers Union | $1,014 |
Mercury | $1,024 |
Quincy Mutual | $1,131 |
Tennessee Farmers | $1,294 |
Erie | $1,381 |
USAA | $1,828 |
Safe Auto | $1,923 |
Acuity | $1,953 |
Progressive | $1,976 |
Nationwide | $2,000 |
Cheapest Insurance Companies | Average Annual Cost |
---|---|
Cincinnati Insurance | $722 |
Texas Farm Bureau | $767 |
Oklahoma Farmers Union | $985 |
Mercury | $1,000 |
Quincy Mutual | $1,107 |
Erie | $1,591 |
Progressive | $1,676 |
State Farm | $1,682 |
USAA | $1,690 |
Safe Auto | $1,819 |
Nationwide | $1,923 |
Tennessee Farmers | $2,084 |
Cheapest Insurance Companies | Average Annual Cost |
---|---|
Cincinnati Insurance | $746 |
Texas Farm Bureau | $803 |
Mercury | $1,018 |
Quincy Mutual | $1,079 |
Erie | $1,198 |
Oklahoma Farmers Union | $1,356 |
USAA | $1,677 |
Acuity | $1,684 |
Vermont Mutual | $1,789 |
Tennessee Farmers | $1,797 |
Arbella | $1,889 |
Country | $1,895 |
Cheapest Insurance Companies | Average Annual Cost |
---|---|
Erie | $973 |
Mercury | $999 |
Quincy Mutual | $1,051 |
Cincinnati Insurance | $1,140 |
Texas Farm Bureau | $1,316 |
USAA | $1,427 |
Progressive | $1,494 |
State Farm | $1,669 |
Arbella | $1,872 |
Acuity | $1,875 |
Tennessee Farmers | $1,878 |
Vermont Mutual | $1,943 |
Cheapest Insurance Companies | Average Annual Cost |
---|---|
Mercury | $1,006 |
Erie | $1,017 |
Quincy Mutual | $1,027 |
Cincinnati Insurance | $1,182 |
USAA | $1,225 |
Texas Farm Bureau | $1,280 |
Progressive | $1,538 |
State Farm | $1,539 |
Acuity | $1,694 |
Vermont Mutual | $1,761 |
Arbella | $1,787 |
Tennessee Farmers | $1,813 |
The make and model of your vehicle, along with the year of manufacture, are the three most important factors in determining your car's value, which in turn is the main factor in determining your car insurance premium. Your own personal driving history, age, marital status, credit score, type of vehicle, coverage levels, and other personal factors are also important components of your car insurance rate.
Many driver discounts are available to people through most major auto insurance companies, such as
Student discounts
Safe drivers
Senior discounts
With all Tesla models, you can get the following car insurance discounts:
Passive restraint systems
Anti-lock brakes
Anti-theft devices
Tesla is the best-selling plug-in and electric car manufacturer with nearly 25% of the electric car market selling to a small higher income group of buyers in the United States with many customers in Arizona, California, Florida, Nevada, Oregon, and Texas. The target market of Tesla is higher income (above 100K+), but with the lower-priced Model 3, Tesla gains more customers with lower income (50 to 100K). All Tesla automobiles have five-star safety ratings, with the Model 3 consistently getting "Top Safety Pick" and 5-star safety and crash test ratings from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). Current Tesla models include the Model 3, S, X, and the Y.
Many consumers are attracted to Tesla automobiles for green technology, safety ratings, and driver-assist technologies, such as the autonomous system AutoPilot, their excellent all-wheel drive (AWD) system, plus the horsepower with the Model S going 0 to 60 in 1.99 seconds. Current automotive parts are sold directly from Tesla and are some of the most expensive repair parts and costs for vehicle owners. Repair parts for Toyota, Honda, and Subaru can be 120 to 284% less expensive. Repairing a Tesla is higher than average since repair parts are more costly and not as available as popular vehicles. For this reason, many Teslas are going to have higher than average car insurance rates to similar cars in its class.
Tesla has an average depreciating value, according to CarandDriver.com, affecting auto insurance rates. As your vehicle's value goes down each year, your auto policy could go down at each renewal. On the other hand, in an auto accident, you need repair parts that rarely go down in price for all Tesla models. This could put you in a difficult situation position since many car insurance companies will subtract depreciation from the amount paid for your insurance claim resulting in a situation where your claim payout doesn't fully cover your repair cost.
Teslas are known for their excellent safety ratings, safety features, 5-star crash test ratings, AutoPilot driver-assist technologies, lowering car insurance rates for drivers with a good driving record, sometimes getting 20% driver discounts for passive restraints, and safety features in Tesla models. The Model 3 is Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) "Top Safety Pick," and the NHTSA consistently gives Tesla Model 3, S, X, and Y top safety ratings each year, lowering your car insurance costs.
AutoInsureSavings.org licensed car insurance agents to recommend comprehensive and collision coverage, uninsured motorist coverage, and roadside assistance for new Tesla automobile owners when buying a car insurance policy.