Leslie Kasperowicz holds a BA in Social Sciences from the University of Winnipeg. She spent several years as a Farmers Insurance CSR, gaining a solid understanding of insurance products including home, life, auto, and commercial and working directly with insurance customers to understand their needs. She has since used that knowledge in her more than ten years as a writer, largely in the insuranc...

Full Bio →

Written by

Joel Ohman is the CEO of a private equity-backed digital media company. He is a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™, author, angel investor, and serial entrepreneur who loves creating new things, whether books or businesses. He has also previously served as the founder and resident CFP® of a national insurance agency, Real Time Health Quotes. He also has an MBA from the University of South Florid...

Full Bio →

Reviewed by Joel Ohman
Founder, CFP®

UPDATED: Jun 24, 2020

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident auto insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one auto insurance provider and cannot guarantee quotes from any single provider. Our partnerships don’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.

A car insurance policy covers more than just your vehicle.

It provides the financial protection needed to fix or replace your car and helps pay for medical bills resulting from an accident.

A policy will protect you if you’re involved in an accident with another motorist who happens to be uninsured or underinsured.

Fact: every state requires car insurance by law, with the exception of New Hampshire.

The bottom line is that having the right car insurance policy can be integral to helping you recover financially after an accident.

And get your car back on the road all that much faster.

Much like other types of auto insurance policies, wading through the details of what each company offers can be extremely time consuming.

Top 5 reasons why drivers changes vehicle insurance companies: Price, Customer Service, Lifestyle change, etc.Note: The most obvious reason drivers change companies is price. However, the 2nd most common reason a driver changes insurers is because of customer service or the lack thereof. In this article I am going to show you a company which aggregates insurers by customer service ratings from around the web.

Clearsurance Ranks Auto Insurance Companies by Reviews

By far the most effective way of judging a car insurance company and its policy offerings is to talk to someone who has already gone through the process of researching, purchasing, and using their policy.

That’s precisely why Clearsurance has taken a whole lot of information collected just this way and built an advanced database for auto insurance buyers.

Here is a link to Clearsurance.

One of the cool features for me personally is the search by rating on their website.

Top auto insurance companies by consumer rating as provided by Clearsurance.com

Image Credit: Clearsurance.com

Note: Illustrated above is a screenshot of Clearsurance’s listings of each insurer by consumer rating. For this illustration I used zip code 45208 which is Cincinnati. The top companies are USAA, California Casualty, and Amica.

I have looked around and I haven’t been able to find similar features which is offered at Clearsurance.

Yes, there is Google and their ratings.

I have to say this may be a little better for those who want to focus solely on vehicle insurance. 

Clearsurance offers an aggregate by best consumer rating for each company in your zip code.

Pretty cool in my opinion. 

Being able to sift through customer experiences and past lessons learned makes selecting your company that much easier.

Clearsurance's top vehicle insurance companies by consumer rating for New York City.

Image Credit: Clearsurance.com

Note: Here is another listing for New York City by best consumer rating provided by Clearsurance.com. The top three vehicle insurance companies are USAA, Amica, and Erie. Again, these are the best companies by consumer rating and nothing else. It doesn’t mean they are the cheapest.

How to Choose a Car Insurance Company

Before doing anything else, take the time to decide what kind of auto insurance coverage you need.

Basic coverage is typically liability insurance in most states.

When looking for a car insurance policy, here are a few factors to take into consideration.

Cost is the Biggest Factor when Choosing a Car Insurance Policy

Many people begin their car insurance research by checking out the cost, and rightly so.

Factors that will influence your car insurance policy premium include, but are not limited to:

Your location

Your age

Your driving history

The make and model of your vehicle

How much you drive

Your gender

Age is a contributing factor for insurers when determining the cost of a premium.Note: Illustrated above is the cost of an average policy for a 20-year old and 55-year-old driver. Your age is a primary factor when insurers determine the price of a premium for you. This is something that is obviously out of your control. There are other ways you can lower your monthly premium.

Any coverage that is required by your state as well as additional coverage you may opt for.

While cost is an excellent place to start, other factors should also influence your decision.

You want to pick a car insurance policy that fits your budget, while also ensuring that your car insurer will be reliable if you need them!

Keep in mind that it may be beneficial to pay a little bit more for additional coverage options that provide you with more thorough and reliable protection in the long run.

Credit Score is factor for insurers to determine a price of a premium for most drivers.Note: Your credit score is another contributing factor to determine how much you pay for a premium. Your credit score shows the insurer how financially responsible you are. Which shows you may be responsible about filing claims. In some states a low credit score can cost you thousands of dollars. California, Hawaii, and Massachusetts ban the use of credit scores.

Customer Service & Availability

How a company treats its customers is a key factor that always plays a role in determining how long they retain those customers.

Be sure to choose an insurance company that will treat you as a valued asset.

Questions to ask yourself to help assess this:

Is your car insurance company available at any hour?

Does the website or call center allow you to reach the person you need to speak to quickly and easily?

Are the staff helpful and knowledgeable about the products they are selling?

Find a company with convenient customer service hours as well as positive reviews from other policyholders.

Clearsurance ranks auto insurance companies by customer reviews similar to JD Power & Associates.

They allow you to see how other consumers rate companies and read reviews to learn from the experiences of other drivers.

A good place to start: the top-ranked car insurance companies list according to consumers.

Below I have outlined the top 10 insurers with the best overall consumer satisfaction. 

CompanyRatingBest Coverage Area
USAA4.7All states*
Amica Mutual4.6Northeast
NJM Group4.4New Jersey & Pennsylvania
Auto-Owners4.4Southeast and Michigan, Minnesota, and Wisconsin.
Travelers4.3West and Southwest
Nationwide4.3All states
State Farm4.2All states
The Hartford4.2All states
California Casualty Group4.2Most states. Offers coverage for firefighters, teachers, and law enforcement.
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

*Insurers like USAA offer coverage in all states. They do not have a specific area where they offer the best coverage. Only an overall from consumer ratings and surveys. USAA only offers coverage to military, former military, and their families.

Claims Process

If you must file a claim with your insurance policy, you want to know that the claims process will be simple and hassle-free.

Your insurance company of choice should:

Make it very clear what type of documentation is needed to file a claim.

Provide fast and efficient service so your claim is processed without delay.

Be empathetic to your situation.

Once again, review each company for accounts of how other customers’ claims have been handled in the past.

Below I have outlined the best insurers for claims. 

Company for Best Claims ServiceConsumer RatingRegion
Amica Mutual4.6New England
Auto-Owners4.4North Central & Southeast
Farmers4.1South Central
Auto Club of California4.1California
The Hartford4.2Mid-Atlantic & New England
Travelers4.3West and Southwest
State Farm4.2All states
Nationwide4.3All states
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

Source: JD Power & Associates

Many insurers offer coverage outside the region. This is to show which insurers has the best claims process for the region. State Farm and Nationwide have good claims process overall and not specifically to one region.

Other Car Insurance Considerations

Every state has different requirements for how much and what type of car insurance a driver needs.

There are 12 no-fault states that require drivers to carry Personal Injury Protection (PIP).

PIP coverage pays for any medical treatment required following a car accident, regardless of who’s found at fault.

Below I have outlined the 12 states which require PIP.

And depending on the state the cost of PIP coverage can be from 9% to 17% of your total coverage. 

No Fault StateMinimum Personal Injury Protection (PIP)Tort Claims Limits
Massachusetts$8,000/per person$2,000
Minnesota$20,000 for medical expenses, $20,000 for non-medical expenses$4,000
New Jersey$15,000 Verbal
New York$50,000Verbal
North Dakota$30,000/person$2,500
Utah$3,000/person $3,000
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

And while the state minimums are enough to trip you up legally if you fail to respect them, keep in mind that in the event of a costly accident, being underinsured is a risk worth avoiding all on its own.

In other words, even if collision and comprehensive insurance are not required by your state, without these coverages you won’t be protected from damage to your car resulting from factors like weather or accidents where you are found at fault.

Optional Coverage

Here are the main optional car insurance additions you might also choose from when assembling an auto insurance policy that works best for you:

Collision insurance repairs damage that results when two vehicles collide with one other, any damage incurred when you hit ice and/or slide into an inanimate object, as well as sudden damage caused by a pothole.

Comprehensive insurance can be added to your basic car policy for coverage from damages that are not the result of a collision, such as theft, vandalism or hail.

These make sense to have if you are driving a newer vehicle since it will be more expensive to fix or replace.

If you do get comprehensive, collision, and other optional coverage which is sometimes called “full coverage” you will see a big difference in price.

Below I have outlined the cost of a liability policy compared to full coverage in various metropolitan cities.

CityBasic CoverageFull CoverageDifference
Los Angeles$1,215$2,965$1,750
New York City$1,875$3,870$1,995
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

Umbrella insurance protects those at risk of being sued for damages to other people’s property or injuries caused to others in an accident, and protects against libel, vandalism, slander and invasion of privacy.

Rental coverage protects drivers using a rented vehicle.

Not a bad protection to have when the car doesn’t even belong to you.

Roadside assistance coverage covers everything from towing services, to gas delivery, a jump start, unlocking doors, tire changes, vehicle transportation, and pulling out your vehicle if it happens to be stuck.

Gap insurance covers the difference between how much you owe on your car, and how much it happens to be worth at the time of an accident.

Final Thoughts

The average driver will spend over $100,000 on car insurance over the course of their life.

Choosing an auto insurance company that will benefit you long term can be a difficult task.

Bottom line is you cannot control the company nor the premiums.

What can you control?

Your driving habits and credit score. 

Maintaining a clean driving record and proper coverage while you drive is the best way to keep your lifelong auto insurance premium as low as possible.





Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.