Phone: 1-(855) 233-7818

Are you currently insured? Yes         No

Start Quote

Liberty Mutual Car Insurance Is Quickly Becoming A Favorite Among A Growing Number Of Drivers, & Average Comparison by State & Age

Since its founding in 1912, Liberty Mutual (LM) has consistently grown to expand the insurance products and services it offers in the United State today.

It’s the nation’s third largest property and casualty provider (based on direct premium) and the seventh largest auto premium provider, with just under five percent of the nation’s market share.

Next time you want to compare quotes and providers, you may want to include Liberty Mutual in your cast of options.

Comparing Liberty with top premium rates for 25 year old.

Note: For a 25 y/o female driver LM was the 4th cheapest carriers out of all that I queried. For more information please see table below.

Comparing to Top Insurers by Driver Profile & Stats

I obtain quotes independently for each of the driver profiles in the table below.

I did this to give you an overview of LM compared to other top insurers.

There are other insurers, however, I thought it would be best to compare them against similar insurers.

For younger drivers quotes came back a little higher than most of the insurers.

For older drivers LM is competitive against any insurer.

Another benefit I found is Liberty will work with those with driver infractions, i.e. not raising your rates too much. As long as they are not major infractions like DUI’s, etc.

Driver ProfileLiberty MutualProgressiveAllstateFarmersState Farm
25 y/o female$1,655$1,543$1,640$1,712$1,512
25 y/o male$1,989$1,890$2,020$2,004$1,903
30 y/o female$1,356$1,287$1,435$1,521$1,240
30 y/o male$1,408$1,398$1,515$1,585$1,340
25 y/o male (1 driving violation)$2,276$2,290$2,280$2,554$2,106
30 y/o female (1 driving violation)$1,588$1,502$1,600$1,812$1,375
40 y/o male$955$980$1,045$1,090$966
45 y/o female$787$767$790$824$742
55 y/o male$634$687$711$690$640
55 y/o female$589$602$632$599$592

Liberty Mutual has All the Standard Options…

If you choose to consider Liberty Mutual for your next or even your first car insurance plan, you will be able to build a policy using all the standard coverage options.

Showing top 5 insurers by comparison for 30 year old male driver.

Note: When I queried for a 30 y/o male driver the LM quote is comparable to Progressive. About $10 more. In this instance LM was the 3rd cheapest carrier. See table above.

You can even start evaluating your possible plan using Liberty’s online calculator.

It will show you changes to your coverage costs and premium rates when you select specific levels and limits from the following basic options:

  • Bodily injury liability coverage
  • Property damage liability coverage
  • Medical payments coverage
  • Collision and comprehensive coverage
    • LM is one of a handful of insurers that require you to buy collision and comprehensive as a package. You can’t have one without the other and you will be required to select separate deductibles for each option.
  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage
    • In some states, LM is able to sell these as separate coverage options and in other states, the two are combined.

Comparing a 45 year old female driver with Liberty and 4 other insurers

Note: I found most all the quotes clustered under $800 for a 45 y/o female. Again, in this instance LM was the 3rd cheapest insurer. See table above for more info.

In a number of states that are no fault, Liberty offers a more robust option to its medical payments coverage, a personal injury protection (PIP) coverage package.

Has many Unique Options Not Found with Other Providers

If you have or decide to move your auto insurance to LM, you can also take advantage of some of the unique add-ons and benefits they offer, including:

Accident Forgiveness

If you have a driving record with no claimable incidents or violations going back five years, even if you’ve been insured with another carrier, Liberty won‘t increase your rates after your first accident covered with them. 

Some extreme cases are excluded and some states limit in how far they can extend this, so consulting with your representative on what applies to you is a good idea.

Top insurer premium prices for 30 year with driving violations

Note: For a female driver with a driving violation LM was the 3rd cheapest provider. This was for a speeding ticket over 11 mph over the limit. LM is competitive against other insurers with a driving infraction on your record.

Unlimited Rental Car Coverage

If your car is damaged in a covered event and you choose to have it repaired at a shop pre-approved by LM, they can arrange for you to have a rental car for as long as it takes to repair your car

This option is not allowed in New York state and you are limited to the rental agencies with service contracts with in your area.)

55 year old driver comparison of insurers with Liberty Mutual

Note: LM is highly competitive for older drivers. In this instance, LM was the cheapest quote for a 55 y/o male driver with no driver infractions.

New Car Replacement

Now a standard feature on all policies, if your new car is totaled during the first year of ownership and its covered by a LM policy they will pay to replace the car.

With no adjustments for depreciation (again, in some states there are limits to what they can offer and you should consult with your representative to see what applies to you.)

LM comparison with 5 state average quotes.

Note: In Texas and California LM is cheaper than the state average. This is when comparing a driver with the same profile and no driving infractions. This includes other carriers which may have offered a policy with less coverage. For top insurers with the same coverage LM would be less for all states.

Lifetime Repair Guarantee

If your car is damaged in an incident covered by LM and you have it repaired at a shop approved and recommended by them, you get a lifetime guarantee for the work.

They will even handle all the arrangements, including transportation of you and your vehicle to and from the repair facility.

State Average quote comparison for Oregon, Utah, Virginia, Nevada, and Illinois.

Note: As illustrated, LM was cheaper in the state of Illinois. The other 4 states, Oregon, Utah, Virginia, and Nevada LM is more expensive on average. During my study I found LM to be cheaper than the average rate with highly populated states.

Plethora of Discounts Offered for Maximum Savings

Like all leading vehilce insurance providers, Liberty offers you the opportunity to save by applying for premium discounts.

Some may seem familiar to you while others may be new.

1Good Student 5 - 30%
2Mature Driver 4 - 20%
3Multi-Car Policy5- 15%
4Anti-Theft5- 15%
5Hybrid Car 0 - 10%
6New Vehicle2 - 7%
7Payment option savings (E-pay)0 - 5%
8New Driver0 - 10%
9New Move0 - 5%
10New Retiree0 - 5%
11Early Shopping0 - 5%
12Occupation Affinity0 - 5%

Liberty Mutual is constantly looking for new ways to help policyholders save money and some of these discounts are a great place to start:

  • Multi-policy or bundling discounts
  • Good student discounts
  • Exclusive group savings
    • If you belong to or work for any of the more than 14,000 employers, associations, credit unions, alumni associations or other groups that are a part of a growing affinity program, you may be eligible for premium savings.
  • Payment option savings
    • Pay in full or arrange for automatic payment and you could save on your premium.
  • New-to-Liberty
    • Add a car or switch a car to a policy and enjoy a discount.
  • Safety and anti-theft devices discounts
  • Hybrid vehicle discounts
  • Multi-car discounts
  • New graduate discounts
    • A special savings offered to new college graduates.
  • New move discount
    • Move to another area and stick with Liberty and they will help you transfer coverage and offer you a discount.
  • New retiree discounts

Some States are Limited in Range & Breadth of Discounts Offered

Liberty Mutual is limited by some states in the full range and breadth of discounts they can offer policyholders.

Be sure you consult with your representative to see just what discounts you are eligible for and be sure your agent works with you to pursue each one that could benefit you.

Comparing Kansas, Maryland, Minnesota, Oklahoma, & South Dakota average quotes

Note: In this instance, LM was cheaper in all of the states except Maryland and South Dakota. Which is negligible and only $1 and $11 respectfully than the average quote.  In Oklahoma, LM averaged nearly 20% lower than the average automobile premium.

State by State Average Rate Hike, Reviews, & Average Customer Satisfaction

Below is a table list of the average percentage rate hike by primary states which Liberty offers premiums.

It is important to note your premium is raised (or lowered) each year depending on circumstances which are not known to me. It is very difficult to retrieve the data for this.

Showing Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Michigan, North Dakota state average with Liberty Mutual.

Note: Only in Colorado and Michigan was LM more expensive than the average premium. In Arizona the quotes are 5% cheaper. In Arkansas the quotes are 13% lower than average. In North Dakota the quotes are 12% cheaper than the average premium.

The only data available is the actual rate hike per year. Each state has an average customer satisfaction which includes claims handling.

The biggest factors from customers when determining a satisfaction is price, claims handling, and amount of coverage.

When comparing the average state quote against LM about half are below the average quote while the other half is more.

There are a few states which LM was substantially lower. For states which are higher it was marginal and never more than 5% higher. Nothing out of the ordinary. 

StatePercentage Rate Hike 2017*State Average QuoteLiberty Mutual QuoteDifferenceRideshare CoverageSatisfaction Out of 5
Idaho 6%$1,326$1,365+$39Y3
Illinois 5%$1,452$1,299-$153Y4
Iowa 6%$1,322$1,422+$100Y3
Kansas 5%$1,348$1,311-$37Y3
New Mexico5%$1,690$1,700+$10Y4
North Dakota6%$1,590$1,422-$168Y4
Ohio 5%$1,634$1,676+$42Y4
South Dakota6%$1,300$1,311+$11N4
Texas 6%$1,990$1,876-$114Y4

Final Thoughts

You will have plenty of options when it comes time for you and your family to acquire or renew your automobile premium.

Next time you’re in the market for some comparison-shopping, consider including Liberty Mutual in your deliberations and you might find yourself a new company.


(Note: This article is intended to be informational only and is in now way a solicitation or a promotion. The author has no affiliation with LM or any other provider.)

Jeffery Davidson

Jeffery Davidson

Jeffrey Davidson has more than 25 years of experience in the industry, from sales and marketing to product development in lines ranging from personal, business and property-casualty. He currently writes on premiums and related topics for Reply!. You can find his article on more coverage options for you and your family.

Comments are closed.

Connect With Us