fbpx
Phone: 1-(855) 233-7818

Utah Cheapest Car Insurance Companies & Minimum Coverage plus Strategies to Save on your Next Policy

Are you currently insured?
Yes No

If you are a driver with a decent driving history, you are going to find the least expensive auto insurance in Utah with Bear River, Allstate, and Auto-Owners.

On average all three carriers can offer quotes from 16 to 24% lower than the median rate for drivers of similar age and profile. 

Other carriers you should put on your list for quotes are Farm Bureau Mutual and American Family.

Farm Bureau Mutual is on the list, though they have a $65 membership fee, the extra fee is probably worth the lower premium costs. 

Depending on the city you reside, both carriers can offer quotes from 15 to 22% lower than the average premium for similar age drivers.

If you are military or former your best option is probably with USAA.

In this article, I am going to cover inexpensive insurers by price, the minimum coverage requirements, and a few cost-savings tips to help you lower your premium.

If you would like to skip to a certain portion of the article, there is a table of contents down a little and to the right.  

Minimum Auto Insurance Coverage Requirements in Utah

CoverageUtah Minimum Liability CoverageRecommended Coverage
Bodily Injury Protection$25,000 per person / $65,000 per accident$100,000 per person / $300,000 per accident
Property Damage$15,000 per accident$100,000 per accident
Medical Payments Coverage (MedPay)$3,000 per person$5,000
Uninsured MotoristN/A$25,000 / $50,000
Comprehensive CoverageN/A$1,000 deductible
Collision CoverageN/A$500 deductible

Utah law requires each driver with a registered vehicle who is a resident of the state to maintain minimum coverage.

The reason is, if you are in an accident, your insurer would be able to pay-out for damages.

Utah low-cost policy choices for 25 y/or drivers.

Bodily Injury Liability

The amount is $25,000 per person and a maximum of $65,000 for two or more persons concerned in an auto accident.

Property Damage Liability

Set at a minimum amount of $15,000 for damage to property, public and private, such as guard rails, traffic signs, or a persons mail box the other driver’s automobile.

When you are comparing quotes you will see the numbers like this: 25/65/15 which are always represented in thousands as mentioned previously.

Cheap policy choices for 30 year old drivers by carrier.

Personal Injury Protection (PIP)

Utah is a “no-fault” state which means each vehicle owner’s insurance will cover their medical expense or vehicle damage no matter who is to blame for the accident.

The purpose of Utah being a no-fault state is to reduce the amount of court filed claims and lawsuits from drivers which in turn helps drive down insurance costs.

Utah lowest premium choices for 40 y/o drivers.

Since Utah is a no-fault state, Personal Injury Protection or (PIP) insurance is required for all drivers.

PIP coverage will cover medical expenses of the insured driver.

In Utah, if you have a health insurance plan, you can opt to get the minimum PIP coverage which is $3,000.

Lowest policy price options for 45 y/o drivers in Utah.

Comprehensive, Collision, & Uninsured Motorist Protection

There is optional coverage you can get which are comprehensive, collision, uninsured motorist protection, and underinsured motorist protection.

Since Utah, like most states, has a significant number of uninsured motorists it is recommended to carry uninsured/underinsured motorist protection or (UM).

It it important to know that Utah has a comparative negligence law which means both drivers can be at-fault during the accident.

Under this law you can collect damages only if you are less than fifty percent “at-fault” during the accident.

When the insurers determine who is less than fifty percent at-fault that person can collect for damages.

Cheapest premiums by price for 55 y/o drivers.

Cheapest Car Insurance by Price in Utah

The three cheapest carriers by price in Utah are Bear River, USAA, and Allstate.

For drivers who do not qualify for USAA, the next best option would be Auto-Owners.

There is one insurer which I would like to give an honorable mention which is Farm Bureau Mutual.

They are more expensive compared to other carriers in the list, Farm Bureau did quite well when I queried for quotes for cities as you will see below in the details.

The reason for a higher price is the membership fee required by them. 

If you are in the market for savings any of the top carriers, such as Allstate, GEICO, etc, are going to offer a competitive quote.

For local companies then you would want to add Bear River and Farm Bureau Mutual to your list of options.

It is important to note that Farm Bureau Mutual requires a membership fee of $65 per year. 

Both of them are offering quotes over 20% lower than average for local regions in Utah.

Utah CompanyAverage Annual Rate 25 Y/O Driver30 Y/O Driver40 Y/O Driver45 Y/O Driver55 Y/O Driver
Bear River$1,251$1,065$789$612$497
USAA$1,254$1,080$800$611$500
Allstate$1,294$1,100$811$634$502
Auto-Owners$1,300$1,111$815$640$511
Farm Bureau Mutual $1,318$1,118$817$648$514
American Family$1,321$1,123$818$656$515
21st Century$1,334$1,124$836$676$518
Travelers$1,337$1,142$854$688$511
GEICO$1,354$1,155$876$696$530
MetLife $1,427$1,179$877$701$533
National General$1,495$1,200$890$722$545
California Casualty$1,500$1,212$900$725$555
AAA$1,529$1,234$921$743$555
Hartford$1,540$1,255$909$765$555
Progressive$1,543$1,290$944$790$580
Unigard$1,714$1,300$956$801$588
Nationwide$1,839$1,345$969$799$590
Chubb$1,927$1,365$987$803$600
Allied$1,957$1,389$1,011$823$611
Liberty Mutual$1,988$1,457$1,045$842$621

The graph below illustration the savings with insurance discounts.

When combined you are able to get 20 percent reduction of your auto premium.

Best Companies by Consumer Rating, Rate Change & Complaints

Below are the best companies by the amount of written premiums, rate change over a 12 to 18 month period, complaints, and consumer rating for each.

The rate change is included since many carriers do raise your rates slightly year over year.

However, if you get a traffic violation your rates can spike significantly.

The amount of complaints is related to the amount of written premiums.

A company with a higher amount of written premiums, there is an obviously likelihood for more complaints.

Out of the 20 carriers in this study there is nothing out of the norm for either the amount complaints based compared to the amount of written premiums.

Neither is anything alarming for the nominal rate hike.

The consumer ratings are taken as an average from JD Power & Associates, AM Best, and other reputable online portals.

Typically, the top carriers have a higher consumer rating.

The local or regional carriers may have a slightly lower rating.

This is normal and shouldn’t be a reason for not doing business with them.

Utah CompanyWritten PremiumsRate Change # of ComplaintsConsumer Rating out of 5 Stars
Bear River$43,326,437+2.1%73.8
USAA$40,543,866+2.1%64.5
Allstate$65,663,786+2.0%244.4
California Casualty$20,232,545+2.2%134.0
21st Century$14,456,583+2.4%64.2
Travelers$13,443,327+2.4%84.3
GEICO$64,550,064+2.5%214.4
MetLife $24,43,554+2.5%44.0
Auto-Owners$18,437,476+2.6%84.2
National General$20,327,379+2.7%53.8
AAA$12,326,587+3.0%43.7
Hartford$11,476,327+2.8%64.0
Farm Bureau Mutual $28,567,476+2.9%44.0
Progressive$98,843,576 +2.4%94.3
Unigard$7,547,693+2.6%33.7
Nationwide$9,454,127+2.7%53.8
Chubb$11,376,487+2.8%63.9
Allied$7,587,565+2.9%83.8
American Family$9,547,587+3.1%63.9
Liberty Mutual$23,436,543 +3.0%84.2

Fine and Penalties for Driving without Coverage in Utah:

  • First offense – minimum $400 fine

  • Second offense – within a three year period $1,000 fine

  • Carry SR-22 when convicted

  • Court costs and fees – approximately $300

Average Premium by City in Utah

Below is a list of 40 cities in Utah and the average premium by price for a 30 year old female driver.

The price of a premium varied from $815 to over $1,200 per year depending on the city or zip code you reside in.

Based on the quotes from the cities, the least expensive are Bear River Mutual, Allstate, and Farm Bureau Mutual.

If your quotes are higher than those listed below than you may have something on your traffic record, a low credit score, lapse in a policy, or a number of other items which may increase your premium.

If you would like a detailed comparison of cities by price in the state of Utah please read further below.

CityAverage PremiumCityAverage Premium
Alpine$952Midway$906
American Fork$946North Ogden$1,187
Bountiful$876Oakley$1,064
Brigham City$912Payson$834
Cedar City$1,004Pleasant Grove$1,059
Coalville$977Providence$938
Cottonwood Heights$965Riverdale$995
Draper$1,007Riverton$1,094
Eagle Mountain$965Roy$1,123
Ephraim$1,056Salina$965
Farr West$1,076Santa Clara$963
Fillmore$997Saratoga Springs$815
Garland$961South Jordan$934
Grantsville$879South Ogden$1,176
Gunnison$856Sunset$1,008
Hurricane$922Tooele$1,056
Lehi$934Trenton$984
Lindon$1,098West Bountiful$997
Manti$945West Valley$999

Salt Lake City, UT

Salt Lake City, UT cheapest premiums by price for 30 to 45 y/o drivers.

For the least expensive premium price in Salt Lake City, drivers should start by getting quotes from Bear River, Farm Bureau Mutual, and Allstate.

I queried each at $878, $925, and $956 per year for a 30-year-old driver.

Which is 16% to 23% lower than the median rate of $1,123 for drivers in Salt Lake.

All carriers illustrated are at least 5% lower than the the “mean” rate for 30 year old drivers.

A 45-year old can get low quotes with Bear River and Farm Bureau Mutual.

Each queried at $630 and $645 respectfully per year for full coverage.

Which is 22% lower than the median quote for similar age drivers in Salt Lake.

In the illustrations, only one neared the average quote, which is American Family at $768.

Salt Lake City Company30 Y/O45 Y/O
Bear River$878$630
Farm Bureau Mutual $925$645
Allstate$956$680
Progressive$1,063 $727
American Family$1,087$768
GEICO$1,108$803

Ogden, UT

Ogden affordable policy choices for all drivers.

Drivers in Ogden can get the cheapest quotes from Bear River, Farm Bureau Mutual, and Progressive.

I queried each at $880, $934, and $956 per year for a 30-year-old driver.

Which is 17 to 24% lower than the average premium price of $1,145 per year in Ogden.

In fact, all of the carriers illustrated are below the median quote and would be worthwhile to get quotes from.

A 45-year old can get the best prices with Bear River, Farm Bureau Mutual, and Progressive.

Each queried at $622, $654, and $659 per year for full coverage.

Or over 22% lower than the median premium price for drivers of similar age and profile.

Ogden Company30 Y/O45 Y/O
Bear River$880$622
Farm Bureau Mutual $934$654
Progressive$956 $659
Allstate$1,032$703
GEICO$1,086$733
American Family$1,133$776

St. George, UT

St. George, UT low-cost policy by price of Bear River, Allstate, Farm Bureau, etc.

Drivers in St. George can get the cheapest auto insurance by getting quotes from Bear River Mutual, Allstate, and Farm Bureau Mutual.

I queried each at $878, $938, and $965 respectfully for a 30-year-old driver.

Which is 16 to 24% lower than the median rate of $1,209 for St. George drivers.

All of the carriers illustrated are lower than the median rate making any of them good contenders to get quotes for comparison.

A 45-year old can get the least expensive premium by getting quotes from Bear River, Allstate, and Farm Bureau Mutual.

Each queried at $630, $654, and $680 respectfully per year for full coverage.

Or 19 to 25% lower than the “mean” quote for drivers of similar age and profile.

Only one spiked above the average quote, American Family, but still a good company to get quotes from since discounts may lower your premium.

St. George Company30 Y/O45 Y/O
Bear River$878$630
Allstate$938$654
Farm Bureau Mutual $965$680
Progressive$1,065 $745
GEICO$1,132$787
American Family$1,176$804

Provo, UT

Provo, UT lowest carriers by price of Farm Bureau, Bear River, Allstate, & Progressive for drivers.

Provo’s average premium cost approximately $1,067 per year for a 30-year-old driver.

If you want to find rates 20% cheaper then start with Farm Bureau, Bear River Mutual, and Allstate.

I queried each at $850, $880, and $932 per year for a 30-year old.

Which is 13 to 20% lower than the median rate in Provo.

Most of the insurers clustered around $850 to $1,000.

And one, American Family, spiked above the median rate.

A 45-year old can get the least expensive quotes with Farm Bureau and Bear River Mutual.

I queried each at $611 and $643 per year for full coverage.

Or each approximately 18 to 25% lower than the average premium for a driver of similar age and profile.

There is a variance of $214 from the lowest to higher illustrated carrier or over 25% difference.

Making it vital to compare quotes to find the most savings while optimizing coverage.

Provo Company30 Y/O45 Y/O
Farm Bureau Mutual $850$611
Bear River$880$643
Allstate$932$687
Progressive$987$737
GEICO$1,068$790
American Family$1,132$825

Logan

Logan low-cost premiums by price for 30 to 45 y/o drivers.

Drivers in Logan can get cheap coverage for their automobile if they get quotes from Bear River, Farm Bureau Mutual, and Progressive.

I queried each at $878, $911, and $943 per year for a 30-year-old driver.

Which is 16% to 22% lower than the average premium for drivers in Logan.

In fact, any of the carriers illustrated are worth getting quotes from since even the highest quote is 6% lower than the median rate.

A 45-year old should get quotes from Bear River and Farm Bureau Mutual.

I queried each at $646 and $656 respectfully per year for full coverage.

Or nearly 21% lower than the median rate for drivers of similar age and profile.

Compared to other cities the variance among the lowest to higher carriers illustrated is less.

Only $165 from the lowest to highest, but a significant amount.

Logan Company30 Y/O45 Y/O
Bear River$878$646
Farm Bureau Mutual $911$656
Progressive$943$708
Allstate$976$722
GEICO$1,043$765
American Family$1,098$811

Park City

Park City cheapest premium options for 30 to 45 y/or drivers.

Park City drivers can get the cheapest premium by getting quotes from Bear River Mutual, Progressive, and Farm Bureau Mutual.

I queried each at $870, $878, and $932 per year for a 30-year-old driver.

Which is 15 to 24% lower than the average premium for drivers of similar age and profile.

Most of the carriers illustrated clustered in the $870 to $1,050 range.

However, there was an increase with American Family at $1,127. American Family is below the median rate however.

A 45-year old can get low quotes with Bear River, Progressive, and Farm Bureau Mutual.

Each queried at $650, $660, and $690 per year for full coverage.

Or over 20% lower than the median rate for drivers in Park City.

There is a variance of $177 among the lowest and highest price insurers or over 21%.

Park City Company30 Y/O45 Y/O
Bear River$870$650
Progressive$878$660
Farm Bureau Mutual $932$690
Allstate$969$726
GEICO$1,022$754
American Family$1,127$827

Moab

Moab cheap policy options for 25 to 55 y/o drivers.

Drivers in Moab can get low premium prices if they get quotes from Bear River, Farm Bureau, and Progressive.

I queried each at $844, $876, and $900 per year for a 30-year old.

Which is 20 to 26% lower than the median rate for drivers of similar age and profile in Moab.

All of the carriers illustrated are over 11% lower than the median rate making all of insurers worthwhile to get quotes from.

A 45-year old can get the best prices with Bear River and Farm Bureau Mutual.

Each queried at a cheap rate of $630 and $633 per year for full coverage.

Or more than 24% lower than the median rate for 45 year old drivers.

In fact, there is a $169 variance among the lowest and highest carriers or 28% difference.

Moab Company30 Y/O45 Y/O
Bear River$844$630
Farm Bureau Mutual $876$633
Progressive$900$665
Allstate$954$711
GEICO$987$743
American Family$1,078$799

Orem

Orem least expensive policy prices for all drivers.

Residents of Orem an get cheap auto insurance if they get quotes from Bear River, Allstate, and Farm Bureau Mutual.

I queried each at $858, $897, and $923 per year for a 30-year-old driver.

Which is 23 to 28% lower than the median rate for drivers of similar age and profile.

Only one carrier spiked above, but still below the median quote, which is American Family.

A 45-year old can get the least expensive quotes with Bear River Mutual and Allstate.

I queried each at $622 and $658 per year for full coverage.

Or 19 to 26% lower then the “mean” rate for drivers about 45 years of age.

However, there is a variance of $210 among the lowest and higher quoted carriers.

Or well over 25% among them.

Orem Company30 Y/O45 Y/O
Bear River$858$622
Allstate$897$658
Farm Bureau Mutual $923$697
Progressive$976$724
GEICO$1,065$765
American Family$1,132$832

Sandy

Sandy low-cost policy quotes for 30 to 45 y/o drivers.

Drivers in Sandy, Utah can get the cheapest premium by getting quotes from Bear River, Farm Bureau Mutual, and Progressive.

I queried each at $876, $903, and $945 per year for a 30-year old.

With quotes clustering under $1,000 for all but American Family any of the insurers are worth getting quotes from.

Each of the carriers are nearly 16% lower them the median rate of $1,149.

With Bear River Mutual 24% lower than the average quote and Farm Bureau 22% lower.

A 45-year old can get affordable quotes with Bear River and Farm Bureau Mutual.

Each queried at $638 and $667 per year for full coverage.

Or approximately 22 to 25% lower than the “mean” quotes for drivers of similar age and profile in Sandy.

Sandy Company30 Y/O45 Y/O
Bear River$876$638
Farm Bureau Mutual $903$667
Progressive$945$700
Allstate$978$713
GEICO$1,033$767
American Family$1,108$826

Layton

Layton, UT affordable premium choices by quote for 30 to 45 y/o drivers.

If you want the cheapest car insurance in Layton then get quotes from Bear River, Farm Bureau, and Progressive.

I queried each at $855, $870, and $921 per year for a 30-year-old driver.

Which is 14% lower than the median rate for drivers of similar age and profile.

Both Allstate and American Family spiked near the “mean” rate.

However, that doesn’t mean to excluded them.

Since discounts and other alternatives could bring the premium down to lower prices.

A 45-year old can get the best prices with Bear River and Farm Bureau Mutual.

Each queried at $624 and $665 respectfully per year for full coverage.

Which is 21 to 25% lower than the “mean” quote for drivers 45 years of age approximately.

Layton Company30 Y/O45 Y/O
Bear River$855$624
Farm Bureau Mutual $870$665
Progressive$921$698
Allstate$980$731
GEICO$1,035$775
American Family$1,085$798

Resources & Department of Motor Vehicles

Department of InsuranceDepartment of TransportationDepartment of Motor Vehicles
350 N. State Street #3110, Salt Lake City, UT 84114
(801) 538-3800
166 Southwell St, Ogden, UT 84404
(801) 620-1600
14555 S, Minuteman Dr, Draper, UT 84020
(801) 297-7780
WebsiteWebsiteWebsite

Conclusion

At AutoInsureSavings we deliver auto insurance rates to you in less than a minute with the advance comparison tool at the top of the page.

You are able to compare as many quotes as you wish, ask for a broker to give you a call, or chat with an agent online.

Everything is set up for your convenience and it is free to find out if you could save forty percent or more on your premium.

Sources

https://www.usa.gov/state-consumer/utah

Utah Auto Claims Information

http://www.rmiia.org/auto

Greg Fowler

Greg Fowler

Managing Member of AutoInsureSavings LLC, Greg has been in the insurance industry for 12 years and enjoys rebuilding vehicles. His goal is to help drivers save on anything related to automobiles. Travel and enjoying the outdoors are some of his hobbies. The best way to reach him is at his Twitter or Facebook Profile.

Comments are closed.