Updated January 7th, 2021
You can find the cheapest car insurance companies in Vermont by getting quotes from Co-operative, Concord, and Progressive.
Depending on the area you reside in, each carrier can offer quotes from 16 to 22% lower than the median quote for similar profile drivers.
Other carriers to put on your list of quotes are Unitrin, National Grange Mutual, and MetLife.
All three insurers can offer quotes from 14 to nearly 20% lower than the average premium.
This article will cover affordable insurers by age and city, minimum requirements, and a few cost-saving tips to help you lower your monthly auto premium.
If you would like to skip to a certain portion of the article, there is a table of contents down a little and to the right.
Note: When querying for quotes, the overall lowest prices for a 25 y/o driver are with Co-op, GEICO, and Concord. The quotes clustered between $1,199 and $1,256 per year. Progressive and Unitrin are certainly worth getting quotes from since they are below the median cost for similar age drivers.
Vermont Minimum Car Insurance Requirements
The state minimum requirements for Vermont are as follows:
| Coverage | Vermont Minimum Liability Coverage | Recommended Coverage |
|---|---|---|
| Bodily Injury Protection | $25,000 / $50,000 | $100,000 / $300,000 |
| Property Damage | $10,000 | $20,000 |
| Medical Payments Coverage | Optional | $5,000 |
| Uninsured Motorist Bodily Injury Coverage | $50,000 / $100,000 | $50,000 / $100,000 |
| Uninsured Motorist Property Damage Coverage | $10,000 with a $150 deductible (In some cases the deductible does not apply) | $20,000 |
| Comprehensive Coverage | Optional | $100 deductible |
| Collision Coverage | Optional | $500 deductible |
Bodily Injury Liability
Bodily injury liability covers hospital costs for the other automobile driver and passengers if the insured party is accountable for the accident.
Under the minimum coverage, the insurance corporation will pay up to $25,000 for a single person and up to $50,000 for all passengers hurt in the accident.
Note: For a 45-year-old driver in Vermont, the quotes clustered between $709 and $779, making all of the insurers illustrated competitive. However, Co-op and GEICO are the most competitive, offering quotes that are nearly 21% lower than the median price for drivers with a similar age and profile.
Property Damage Liability
Covers for physical damages to the other driver’s automobile and public property like guard rails, places or business, or traffic signs.
It includes personal property like someone’s home, garage door, or mailbox.
Under the minimum coverage, the insurance corporation will pay up to $10,000 for damages sustained.
Note: As illustrated in the chart above, the cheapest premium by price for a 55-year-old driver is with Co-op, GEICO, and Concord. With older drivers, particularly those around 55 years of age, the insurers are extremely competitive. For drivers with good credit and no recent traffic violations, any of the carriers above would want to insure you. And they should be nearly 18% lower than the median premium price compared to other insurers.
Uninsured Motorist Protection
The state of Vermont also requires drivers to carrying uninsured motorist protection or (UM) on the policy for $50,000 for one passenger and up to $100,000 for more than one passenger in a vehicle during an accident with an uninsured driver.
Uninsured motorist property damage liability is required on the policy with the minimum amount of $10,000.
Cheapest Auto Insurance Companies in Vermont
Out of the 10+ insurers in the list below, the least expensive overall are Co-op, GEICO, and Concord.
Concord is under Auto-Owners group coverage.
Most of the time, when I queried for quotes for the state of Vermont and various cities, all three carriers are approximately 16 to 22% lower than the median rate.
This applied to drivers from 25 to 55 years of age.
When I queried for quotes, this was for a male driver with no traffic violations and good credit.
The next three cheapest are Progressive, Unitrin (owned by Kemper), and National Grange Mutual.
Depending on the city or zip code you reside in, any of the three carriers recently mentioned may be cheaper than the “top 3” least expensive.
As you will see in the detailed comparison of major cities below.
Your best bet is to compare quotes at the end of the day, and the list is only a guide or a starting point to find additional savings.
| Vermont Company | Average Annual Rate 25 Y/O Driver | 30 Y/O Driver | 40 Y/O Driver | 45 Y/O Driver | 55 Y/O Driver |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Co-op Insurance | $1,199 | $987 | $789 | $709 | $601 |
| GEICO | $1,234 | $1,021 | $804 | $713 | $611 |
| Concord | $1,256 | $1,055 | $810 | $756 | $614 |
| Progressive | $1,267 | $1,084 | $815 | $776 | $619 |
| Unitrin | $1,367 | $1,100 | $845 | $779 | $645 |
| National Grange Mutual | $1,389 | $1,116 | $880 | $779 | $678 |
| Allstate | $1,411 | $1,132 | $911 | $809 | $654 |
| State Farm | $1,524 | $1,267 | $918 | $834 | $652 |
| Travelers | $1,590 | $1,280 | $987 | $856 | $689 |
| 21st Century | $1,622 | $1,314 | $1,055 | $903 | $698 |
| Farmers | $1,623 | $1,342 | $1,096 | $965 | $709 |
| Union Mutual | $1,654 | $1,370 | $1,133 | $1,008 | $756 |
| MetLife | $1,765 | $1,429 | $1,249 | $1,007 | $798 |
Best Companies by Consumer Rating, Rate Change, & Complaints
Below are 11 top carriers in Vermont’s state with the number of written premiums, rate change over a 12 to 18 month period, complaints, and consumer rating.
I have included the number of written premiums since the number of complaints is include too.
This is important since the number of complaints is relative (normally) to the number of written premiums.
For example, if a company has millions of premiums, the likelihood of more complaints is higher.
There is nothing out of the ordinary that should deter you from buying a policy from any of the carriers below.
The rate change ranges from 2 to 3.9% depending on the carrier and is not out of the ordinary either.
Typically, the top companies raise their rates a little less than smaller local companies.
The consumer rating average is from JD Power & Associates, AM Best, and other reputable online rating companies.
What I did it take an average among all of them.
Typically the larger companies have a higher rating, and smaller ones are slightly lower.
Nothing in the details should prevent you from buying a policy from any of the listed insurers.
| Vermont Company | Written Premiums | Rate Change | # of Complaints | Rating out of 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GEICO | $21,343,000 | +2.8% | 9 | 4.7 |
| Concord General Mutual | $7,435,465 | +3.6% | 6 | 4.2 |
| Progressive | $23,456,476 | +2.7% | 14 | 4.7 |
| Essentia | $3,442,563 | +3.9% | 1 | 4.1 |
| Liberty Mutual | $14,574,492 | +2.7% | 11 | 4.7 |
| Nationwide | $8,548,227 | +2.9% | 8 | 4.5 |
| National Grange Mutual | $9,327,433 | +3.3% | 6 | 4.2 |
| State Farm | $20,378,030 | +3.0% | 19 | 4.7 |
| Hartford | $11,328,478 | +3.2% | 9 | 4.5 |
| Vermont Mutual | $7,432,376 | +3.9% | 2 | 4.0 |
| Allstate | $18,233,873 | +3.1% | 13 | 4.3 |
Vermont’s Penalties – Driving without Insurance
-
First offense – $250 fine
-
Second offense – $500 fine
-
Required to file an SR-22 with the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV)
-
When convicted, your license and registration are reinstated after you show proof of financial responsibility with an SR-22
Average Premium by City
The table below lists 22 less populated cities and the average premium price for a 30-year-old driver.
Included is the percentage difference from the state average.
Most of the time, when I queried for quotes, they were less than the state average price for a premium in Vermont.
If you receive higher quotes than those below,w you may have a mark on your traffic record, a low credit score, or possibly a lapse in your premium.
Several other factors raise your premium above the average price.
If you are a young driver, less than 25 years old, your prices will be much higher than those listed below.
The quotes are for a 30-year-old male driver with no traffic violations and good credit.
If you would like a detailed comparison of Vermont’s most populated cities, please read further below.
| City | Rate | % Change vs Average | City | Rate | % Change vs Average |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arlington | $1,093 | -5% | Dover | $1,042 | -5% |
| Barnette | $1,043 | -5% | Enosburg | $1,039 | -5% |
| Barton | $1,022 | -7% | Hardwick | $1,087 | -4% |
| Bethel | $936 | -7% | Hydeville | $1,112 | -4% |
| Bondville | $965 | -7% | Jericho | $1,114 | -4% |
| Bradford | $996 | -7% | Lyndon | $1,011 | -5% |
| Brandon | $1,076 | -5% | Morristown | $1,025 | -5% |
| Castleton | $1,011 | -5% | Newport | $1,076 | -4% |
| Chelsea | $1,043 | -5% | Peacham | $1,097 | -4% |
| Cornwall | $1,099 | -4% | Swanton | $1,002 | -5% |
| Dorset | $1,113 | -4% | Westminster | $1,028 | -5% |
Burlington, VT
The average insurance rate in Burlington, Vermont, is $1,100.
The least expensive insurers are Progressive, Co-op, and Concord.
I queried each at $877, $909, $1,005 per year for a 30-year-old driver.
Or approximately 15 to 20% lower than the median quote for similar age drivers in Burlington.
A 45-year old can find affordable quotes with Progressive, Co-op, and Concord.
I queried each at $622, $679, and $709 per year for full coverage.
Which is 19% cheaper than the average premium quote for similar profile drivers.
| Burlington Company | 30 Y/O | 45 Y/O |
|---|---|---|
| GEICO | $865 | $611 |
| Progressive | $877 | $622 |
| Co-op | $909 | $679 |
| Concord | $1,005 | $709 |
| Unitrin | $1,008 | $754 |
| National Grange Mutual | $1,113 | $813 |
Essex Junction, VT
If you need cheap auto insurance in Essex Junction, get quotes from Co-op, Progressive, and Concord.
I queried each at $812, $899, and $912 for a 30-year-old driver.
Which is 16 to 22% lower than the median quote for similar profile drivers.
Unitrin is another low-quote option since they are 15% lower at $915.
A 45-year old can find inexpensive quotes with Co-op, Progressive, and Concord.
I queried each at $598, $643, $680 respectfully per year for full coverage.
Which is 16 to 21% lower than the median quote for Essex Junction drivers.
| Essex Company | 30 Y/O | 45 Y/O |
|---|---|---|
| Co-op | $812 | $598 |
| GEICO | $843 | $622 |
| Progressive | $899 | $643 |
| Concord | $912 | $680 |
| Unitrin | $915 | $708 |
| National Grange Mutual | $954 | $725 |
Rutland, VT
Drivers in Rutland can find quotes clustering between $756 and $848.
Your best options are with Co-op, Progressive, and Concord.
I queried each at $756, $809, and $843 respectfully for a 30-year-old driver.
Which is 14 to 19% lower than the citywide average premium in Rutland.
A 45-year old can find the best options with Co-op and Progressive.
I queried each at $547 and $580 per year for full coverage.
Or approximately 16 to 20% lower than the average premium for 45-year-old drivers.
| Rutland Company | 30 Y/O | 45 Y/O |
|---|---|---|
| Co-op | $756 | $547 |
| GEICO | $766 | $560 |
| Progressive | $809 | $580 |
| Concord | $843 | $613 |
| Unitrin | $845 | $620 |
| National Grange Mutual | $848 | $640 |
Bennington, VT
The average rate for drivers in Bennington is $1,000 for a 30-year-old driver and $850 for a 45-year-old driver.
Your lowest options are with Co-op, Progressive, and Concord.
I queried each at $721, $745, and $765 per year for a 30-year-old driver.
Which is 16% lower than the median quote for similar age drivers.
A 45-year old can find cheap quotes with Co-op.
I queried them at $510 per year for full coverage.
Other carriers to put on your list of quotes are Unitrin and Grange Mutual.
Both carriers can offer competitive quotes for all age drivers.
| Bennington Company | 30 Y/O | 45 Y/O |
|---|---|---|
| Co-op Insurance | $721 | $510 |
| GEICO | $726 | $525 |
| Progressive | $745 | $540 |
| Concord | $765 | $569 |
| Unitrin | $802 | $600 |
| National Grange Mutual | $807 | $607 |
Battleboro, VT
Drivers in Battleboro can find the cheapest car insurance with Co-op, Progressive, and Concord.
I queried each at $767, $787, and $806 respectfully per year for a 30-year-old driver.
Which is approximately 16 to 21% lower than the citywide average premium.
A 45-year old can quotes clustering between $526 and $648.
Your best options are with Co-op and Progressive.
Each queried at $540 and $550 per year for full coverage.
Which is 19% lower than the median quote for similar profile drivers.
Unitrin and Grange are two carriers to put on your list for quotes.
Since each is 10% lower than the median rate for drivers in Battleboro.
| Battleboro Company | 30 Y/O | 45 Y/O |
|---|---|---|
| GEICO | $755 | $526 |
| Co-op | $767 | $540 |
| Progressive | $787 | $550 |
| Concord | $806 | $602 |
| Unitrin | $833 | $622 |
| National Grange Mutual | $856 | $648 |
Montpelier, VT
Drivers in Montpelier can get cheap auto insurance if they get quotes from Concord, Progressive, and Co-op.
I queried each at $875, $904, and $915 for a 30-year-old driver.
Which is 14 to 18% lower than the median rate for the city.
Out of all the carriers illustrated, National Grange Mutual is near the median rate.
A 45-year old can get the lowest premium with Concord, Progressive, and Co-op.
Each queried at $612, $640, and $680 per year for full coverage.
Or approximately 17% lower than the “mean” rate for drivers in Montpelier.
Unitrin and National Grange are equally good contenders with quotes below the median rate.
| Montpelier Company | 30 Y/O | 45 Y/O |
|---|---|---|
| Concord | $875 | $612 |
| Progressive | $904 | $640 |
| Co-op | $915 | $680 |
| Unitrin | $965 | $723 |
| GEICO | $980 | $743 |
| National Grange Mutual | $1,043 | $803 |
Stowe
Drivers in Stowe can get a low premium by getting quotes from Concord, Co-op, and Progressive.
I queried each at $880, $924, and $965 per year for a 30-year-old driver.
All three are over 14% lower than the median rate for a similar age and profile driver.
Unitrin and National Grange Mutual should definitely be on your list to get quotes too.
Since both approaches, 10% lower than the median quote.
A 45-year old can get the best prices with Concord, Co-op, and Progressive.
Each queried at $623, $656, and $687 per year for full coverage.
Or approximately 12 to 16% lower than the median quote for similar age drivers.
| Stowe Company | 30 Y/O | 45 Y/O |
|---|---|---|
| Concord | $880 | $623 |
| Co-op | $924 | $656 |
| Progressive | $965 | $687 |
| Unitrin | $1,043 | $728 |
| GEICO | $1,067 | $758 |
| National Grange Mutual | $1,080 | $812 |
Middlebury
Residents of Middlebury can get inexpensive premiums by getting quotes from Unitrin, Concord, and Co-op.
I queried each at $890, $936, and $968 per year for a 30-year-old driver.
Which is 16 to 19% lower than the median rate for drivers with a similar age and profile.
However, it should be noted that National Grange was quoted near the median rate.
A 45-year old can get the lowest policy price with Unitrin, Concord, and Co-op.
Each queried at $687, $700, and $712 per year for full coverage.
Which is approximately 16% lower than the “mean” quote citywide.
| Middlebury Company | 30 Y/O | 45 Y/O |
|---|---|---|
| Unitrin | $890 | $687 |
| Concord | $936 | $700 |
| Co-op | $968 | $712 |
| Progressive | $1,055 | $725 |
| GEICO | $1,089 | $780 |
| National Grange Mutual | $1,132 | $832 |
Barre
The average premium price in Barre is higher than in other cities in the state.
To get the cheapest premium, start by getting quotes from Concord, Unitrin, and Co-op.
I queried each at $900, $923, and $956 per year for a 30-year-old driver.
Which is 13 to 15% lower than the median rate for drivers of similar age and profile.
Although higher in price, Progressive and National Grange Mutual are worth getting quotes from since discounts or other benefits may drive down the cost.
A 45-year old can get the cheapest premium with Concord and Unitrin.
I queried each at $698 and $732 respectfully for a 45-year-old driver.
Or approximately 16% lower than the average policyholder’s price for a premium in Barre.
| Barre Company | 30 Y/O | 45 Y/O |
|---|---|---|
| Concord | $900 | $698 |
| Unitrin | $923 | $732 |
| Co-op | $956 | $765 |
| Progressive | $1,031 | $832 |
| GEICO | $1,065 | $850 |
| National Grange Mutual | $1,154 | $866 |
Saint Albans
If you are in the market for an inexpensive premium in St. Albans, start by getting quotes from Co-op, Concord, and Unitrin.
I queried each at $880, $911, and $945 per year for a 30-year-old driver.
Which is 13 to 16% lower than the average premium citywide.
Progressive is a good option, too, with a lower than average quote at $987.
A 45-year old can get a cheap premium with Co-op, Concord, or Unitrin.
I queried each at $698, $708, and $754 respectfully per year for full coverage.
Or approximately 14 to 17% lower than the “mean” rate for St. Albans drivers.
Other companies to consider are Progressive, and National Grange Mutual since both are below the median quote for similar age drivers.
| Saint Albans Company | 30 Y/O | 45 Y/O |
|---|---|---|
| Co-op | $880 | $698 |
| Concord | $911 | $708 |
| Unitrin | $945 | $754 |
| Progressive | $987 | $779 |
| GEICO | $1,032 | $832 |
| National Grange Mutual | $1,127 | $858 |
Essex
Drivers in Essex can get cheap car insurance by getting quotes from Co-op, Concord, and Unitrin.
I queried each at $896, $932, and $967 per year for a 30-year old.
Which is 14 to 17% lower than the median rate for a driver of similar age and profile.
Both Progressive and MetLife are good contenders for a cheaper rate, too, with quotes at $1,087 and $1,128 respectfully for full coverage.
A 45-year old can get the least expensive premium with Co-op, Concord, and Unitrin.
I queried each at $697, $758, and $779 per year for full coverage.
Which is 12 to 16% lower than the median rate for a 45-year-old driver in Essex.
There is significant variance among the lowest, Co-op, and the highest, MetLife, which is $157.
Or over 22% difference among them.
| Essex Company | 30 Y/O | 45 Y/O |
|---|---|---|
| Co-op | $896 | $697 |
| Concord | $932 | $758 |
| Unitrin | $967 | $779 |
| Progressive | $1,087 | $832 |
| MetLife | $1,128 | $854 |
| National Grange Mutual | $1,165 | $903 |
Insurance Resources & DMV Information
| Department of Insurance | Department of Transportation | Department of Motor Vehicles |
|---|---|---|
| 89 Main St, Montpelier, VT 05602 (802) 828-3301 | 380 Ballard Rd, Milton, VT 05468 (802) 524-6033 | 4 Market St, South Burlington, VT 05403 (802) 828-2085 |
| Website | Website | Website |
Sources
http://www.dfr.vermont.gov/insurance
https://www.co-opinsurance.com/
http://www.mass.gov/vermont.pdf
http://www.concordgroupinsurance.com/
