How Much Do You Get For Your Vehicle If It Is Totaled? Negotiating Strategies & Tactics to Squeeze a Few More Dollars out of the Insurer

Were you recently involved in an accident that totaled your car?

One of the most common misunderstandings that most people have when dealing with an insurance company is the belief that they will be paid the price they paid for their car if it is totaled.

Unfortunately, that is not the case – and in most situations, you might not even get true full market value for your car.

This is more common than you think.

According to NADA.org (National Automobile Dealers Association) more than 5 million vehicles are totaled each year.

So what can you do about it?

Make sure you have comprehensive and collision coverage before you start to negotiate with any insurer about your totaled vehicle. 

How Much will I get for a Totaled Car?

Your insurer is not going to give you more money for your car simply because you think it is worth more than their estimate.

The bad news is, if you want more money for your car, you’re going to have to negotiate for it.

The good news is, as you continue reading, you’ll better understand how your company determines the value of your car.

You’ll also learn about a few strategies that you can use to maximize the amount that your insurer will give you for your car if it is has been totaled.

Note: The average vehicle can depreciate from 17% to 30% in the first year according to NADA. Some depreciate up to 38%. When you are attempting to negotiate with an insurer after a total loss claim you are likely to find out your vehicle is not worth as what you expect.

For now I will have to explain Fair Market Value of a car.

This is what insurers are going to use to determine how much your car is worth at the time of the accident. There is information you might want to be aware of too.

Some insurers are NOT going to use the “pre-accident” value, but the “investment” of the repaired vehicle. I will go into more detail below. 

How do Insurers Determine the Fair Market Value of a Vehicle?

The definition of fair market value is when a buyer or seller can agree on a price.

After you’ve been involved in an accident, an adjuster from your carrier will determine the damage to your car.

If the adjuster deems the car to be totaled, a value must then be assigned to the car.

Totaled Loss Claim vs Actual Cash Value

If you have been in an automobile accident and the insurer is determining if your vehicle is a total loss you have to carry comprehensive and collision coverage.

If not, then you would have to pay out of pocket. 

Many insurers are going to look at the cost of the repairs, the salvage value of the vehicle, and the cost to the insurer while the vehicle is being repaired.

If the value of the restored vehicle is more than getting a new one the insurer will file for a total loss.

It wouldn’t be smart financially to repair your car.

Below is a table of the total loss value for a vehicle in each state.

For example, in Arkansas if your $10,000 vehicle needs $7,500 in repairs it would be a total loss. In Colorado if your $10,000 vehicle needs $10,000 in repairs it would be a total loss. 

What is considered a total loss varies from state to state.

Some use what is called the Total Loss Threshold or TLT where the damage needs to exceed a certain percentage of the vehicle’s value.

The majority of states use what is called Total Loss Formula or TLF where the salvage value and cost of repairs exceed the car’s actual cash value.

State	TLT / TLF	State	TLT / TLF
Alabama	75%	Montana	75%
Alaska	TLF	Nebraska	65%
Arizona	TLF	Nevada	50%
Arkansas	70%	New Hampshire	75%
California	TLF	New Jersey	TLF
Colorado	100%	New Mexico	TLF
Connecticut	TLF	New York	75%
Delaware	TLF	North Carolina	75%
Florida	80%	North Dakota	75%
Georgia	TLF	Ohio	TLF
Hawaii	TLF	Oklahoma	60%
Idaho	TLF	Oregon	80%
Illinois	TLF	Pennsylvania	TLF
Indiana	70%	Rhode Island	TLF
Iowa	75%	South Carolina	75%
Kansas	75%	South Dakota	TLF
Kentucky	75%	Tennessee	75%
Louisiana	TLF	Texas	100%
Maine	75%	Utah	TLF
Maryland	TLF	Vermont	TLF
Massachusetts	75%	Virginia	75%
Michigan	70%	Washington	TLF
Minnesota	TLF	West Virginia	75%
Mississippi	80%	Wisconsin	70%
Missouri	TLF	Wyoming	75%

When assessing the value of your car, the adjuster and the insurer will do the following:

• Evaluate the condition of the car prior to the accident

• Research the market value of your car

• Get 3rd party appraisals of your car

The adjuster will determine if your car is in excellent, good, fair, or poor condition.

Even if you kept your car in pristine shape prior to the accident, the car is not likely to receive an excellent rating unless it is a few months old or less.

You have to think like an unpressured buyer or seller when attempting to determine the fair market value of vehicle. This is what insurers do. 

Once the adjuster has done the job and filed the necessary paperwork, the insurer takes over to figure out the market value of your car.

While one might think that all they need to do is use Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds.com, most companies choose to use their own methods.

The reason is simple – they want to pay out as little as possible.

Although every insurer is different, most will contact local dealerships and 3rd party companies to see what a car similar to yours is selling for in your area.

Whether they look at all the vehicles or a small scale is not known, so it is best that you do your own research.

If you’re still asking the question, “How much will an insurance company give me for my car?” It is at this point that you’ll be able to find your answer.

Your carrier will likely contact you with the dollar number they are willing to pay out for your totaled vehicle.

If you feel that they undervalued your car, then it is important that you speak up sooner rather than later. Ask for a copy of the report they compiled, including all of the information they used to determine your car’s value.

Believe it or not, there are many cases in which customers have challenged the value set by top carriers, and as a result, received an extra $1,000 or more for their car.

Best Auto Insurance Companies for Claims & Totaled Vehicles

Based on consumer surveys and ratings from reputable sources the top companies to work with when dealing with claims and/or totaled vehicles are USAA, Travelers, Auto-Owners, and Amica.

All of them ranked 98 out of 100, except USAA, which ranked 100 out of 100.

Included in the list rounds out the top 17 companies for claims sanctification across the United States.

If by chance you are going through the brutal process of a totaled car claim with an insurer and want to switch, below are reputable companies with good financial strength.

Company	Claims Service	AM Best Rating	Score (Out of 100)
USAA	100	A++	97
Travelers	98	A++	91
Auto Owners	98	A+	90
Amica	98	A++	95
Liberty Mutual	96	A	87
AAA of Southern California	96	A+	94
GEICO	94	A++	89
CSAA Group (AAA)	93	A	91
Progressive	93	A+	89
State Farm	92	A++	91
Allstate	92	A+	88
Nationwide	92	A+	89
Hartford	90	A+	88
American Family	88	A	89
Safeco	84	A	88
Farmers	83	A	82
Erie	80	A+	86

How to Negotiate to get more Value for Your Totaled Vehicle

Here’s what you should do.

If you want the extra money that you deserve for your totaled car, don’t just sit around and expect your insurer to pay it out.

Instead, consider using any and all of these tactics:

• Do your own research.

• Contact local dealerships.

• Keep detailed records and take into account any extra options and features your car had.

• Compare your research with that of the insurer.

• Be courteous.

• You are attempting to get the fair market value of the vehicle – not what you think it is worth. What the market or unbiased buyer or seller would agree on a price. 

The best thing you can do when negotiating how much you will get from an insurer for your car is to prepare yourself as best as possible.

Research the recent sales of your vehicle online, as well as current sale prices.

How to Determine the Fair Market Value of a Vehicle on Your Own

Not sure where to start?

Consider Autotrader.com or Edmunds.com to gather data.

In addition to using the Internet as a resource to gather sales data, contact local dealerships that sell a make and model that is similar to your vehicle.

They will likely provide with you a higher sales price, which will only work out in your favor.

Lastly, consider using Kelley Blue Book to get the fair market value of your vehicle.

As you conduct your research, make sure to keep detailed records of all the data you gather from all of your sources.

Try to get any sales figures in writing, as you’ll be able to use these to negotiate more money.

Be sure to also locate any information related to the extra options that your car had.

From special car stereos to reverse cameras, those added features could add a bit more money to the check from your insurance company.

Once you’ve compiled all of your data, and received the detailed information from the insurance company, it’s now time to compare your research.

When you conduct your research and come up with a “reasonable” fair market price then try to negotiate a few more dollars out of the insurer. 

Look to see where you might be able to squeeze your provider for the extra dollars you deserve.

When you contact your insurance company to state your case and negotiate for the higher value, it is also best to be courteous.

At the same time, however, stand your ground.

The agent at your insurance company will be far more likely to help you out if you come across as confident yet cordial.

Final Thoughts

By being informed and following the suggested tactics, you should be able to negotiate more money, no matter what kind of answer your insurance company gives after you ask them what they will give you for your car.

Sources