Leslie Kasperowicz holds a BA in Social Sciences from the University of Winnipeg. She spent several years as a Farmers Insurance CSR, gaining a solid understanding of insurance products including home, life, auto, and commercial and working directly with insurance customers to understand their needs. She has since used that knowledge in her more than ten years as a writer, largely in the insuranc...

Full Bio →

Written by

Joel Ohman is the CEO of a private equity-backed digital media company. He is a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™, author, angel investor, and serial entrepreneur who loves creating new things, whether books or businesses. He has also previously served as the founder and resident CFP® of a national insurance agency, Real Time Health Quotes. He also has an MBA from the University of South Florid...

Full Bio →

Reviewed by Joel Ohman
Founder, CFP®

UPDATED: Nov 26, 2020

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident auto insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one auto insurance provider and cannot guarantee quotes from any single provider. Our partnerships don’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.

Wawanesa is a solid, trustworthy company with competitive rates, straightforward practices, and a good reputation.

If you are a driver with a good driving history in California or Oregon you should definitely put them on your bucket list to get quotes. 

On the flip side, if you have a poor driving record, you will see your premiums skyrocket making shopping elsewhere a better option.

Comparing quotes by price from Grange, Wawanesa, Progressive, Pemco, and Chubb for 25 y/o drivers. Note: In the illustration above, Wawanesa is the 3rd least expensive carrier offering quotes at $1,844 per year for full coverage in Oregon. Chubb is more expensive with a quote at $1,968. PEMCO offers higher quotes with a price at $1,870. Progressive and Grange offer quotes substantially lower for a 25 year old driver.

The fact of the matter is, you are going to find every single auto insurance company with negative reviews.

Wawanesa is no exception.

With JD Power & Associates ranking them in line with USAA and Ameriprise Financial Services this is a company I had to take a look at. 

Who is Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company?

Wawanesa was founded in Wawanesa, Manitoba, Canada in 1896 specializing in farmers’ mutual insurance.

In 1975 they started selling insurance in California then branched out to Oregon. 

The US branch is a subsidiary of The Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company, one of the largest insurance carriers in Canada.

They currently issue policies in two states, California and Oregon.

While they sell homeowners, renters, and condo insurance, auto is their main product.

Insurance quotes compared for 30 y/o driver from Grange, Progressive, PEMCO, and Chubb. Note: The two companies which are able to offer lower quotes for a 30 year old driver are Grange and Progressive. Both offering quotes at $1,355 and $1,322 respectfully. Wawanesa offers quotes at $1,411 which is competitive. Chubb and PEMCO offer fairly higher rates with quotes at $1,498 and $1,555.

Solid Reputation Built on Trust

Wawanesa has received extremely good marks from independent reviewers like JD Power & Associates and the Better Business Bureau.

In 2018, JD Power listed them as the third best auto insurance company in California and, in 2013, they had the number one spot.

A.M. Best has rated them an 85 out of a possible 100. 

They also have an A+ rating with the BBB.

Below is a list of their recent ratings: 

AM BestA
JD Power & AssociatesTop 3 company last five years in California
Better Business BureauA+
NAIC Complaint Index.74 (Above Average)
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

How do Premium Rates Compare Against the Average?

The average cost of auto insurance in California is $79 per month for minimum coverage. 

The quote I received from them for a 2016 Honda Civic, male driver with the minimum required insurance in Long Beach was $49.44.

Comparing auto insurance quotes by price in California with Progressive, Wawanesa, Century National, Nationwide, and Allstate.Note: Illustrated above are the yearly quotes for a 40 year old male driver in Long Beach, California with minimum coverage only. The two companies cheaper than Wawanesa ($600) are Progressive and Century National. Both offering quotes at $554 and $567 per year for minimum coverage. Nationwide and Allstate are more expensive with quotes fairly higher priced at $621 and $648 respectfully.

That is pretty big savings!

Bear in mind, I had to use a driver with a clean record to get a competitive price.

According to their website, if you have any negative marks, you are likely to see much higher rates.

Quotes Compared with Competitors

Below is a list of direct competitors for companies licensed to do business in either California or Oregon.

The two areas where Wawanesa is offering policies.

Depending on your state or zip code you reside your quotes may vary.

When I did my analysis of quotes I noticed that younger drivers are not as competitive for the company.

Only two are higher PEMCO and Chubb.

State Farm and Progressive are consistently able to offer lower quotes throughout the age spectrum for drivers with a good driving history.

For older drivers, Wawanesa is very competitive with a quote $611 per year for full coverage for a 55 year old driver.

The only other two offering lower quotes are State Farm and Progressive.

Their sweet spot seems to be for drivers from 35 to 55 years of age and older. 

After doing my analysis of quotes, if you are a driver with a good driving history, Wawanesa is certainly a company to put on your list to get quotes.

CompanyPremium 25 Y/O Driver30 Y/O Driver35 Y/O Driver45 Y/O Driver55 Y/O Driver
Grange $1,766$1,355$1,238$1,043$690
State Farm$1,735$1,378$1,164$986$610
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

How do They Keep Premiums so Low?

The two main cost savers I found are their lack of advertising and the fact they attempt to exclusively insure good drivers.

Wawanesa prides themselves on mainly operating through direct solicitation.

This means that they do not hire independent insurance agents to find customers or advertise.

They contact potential clients direct, usually by mail.

The money they save by doing this is passed on to the client through low rates.

Wawanesa premium quotes compared by price for 35 y/o driver against Farmers, State Farm, PEMCO, and Chubb.Note: For a 35 year old driver the cheapest rates are found with State Farm and Wawanesa. Both offering quotes at $1,164 and $1,200 respectfully per year for full coverage. Chubb, Farmers, and PEMCO are all priced higher. A sweet spot for the company is older drivers from 35 years of age and up. Which is typical of most auto insurance companies.

Word of Mouth Advertising

The company claims over 90% of their new customers come as a result of referrals from current clients.

In addition to the advertising savings, the company must be doing something right if customers are recommending the company to their friends.

It is a good sign that Wawanesa has managed to stay in business for close to 50 years in the US through word-of-mouth referrals.

By purposely relying on referrals as their main method of growing their clientele, they have made it clear that customer satisfaction is important to them.

Seeking Only the Good Drivers?

Wawanesa’s biggest drawback is how strict they are in driver requirements.

However, only insuring low risk drivers is another way they save money which can be passed on as savings to their customers.

On their website they state up front they only insure state-defined “good drivers”.

Who is a “Good Driver”?

For California, to qualify as a good driver you cannot have more than one “point” in traffic violations or at fault accidents in the past three years.

Almost all traffic convictions are counted as one point.

Most at fault traffic accidents count as one or two points depending on whether or not there was bodily damage.

A perfect record will get you pretty amazing rates that are lower than their competitors.

A record with some blemishes but still qualifying as a good driver will still get you insured but rates will be higher.

If you are anything other than a good driver, you might be out of luck with Wawanesa.

Comparison of premiums by price for 45 y/o driver from Farmers, State Farm, PEMCO, and Chubb.Note: In the illustration above, Wawanesa is the cheapest option by price with a quote at $944 for a 45 year old driver. Note included is Progressive which is the only company offering lower quotes. (please see table above). All other companies including Farmers, State Farm, PEMCO, and Chubb offer higher quotes.

Coverage & Policy Options

If you do qualify for Wawanesa’s low rates, what types of coverage options are there?

They are pretty straight forward in what options they provide without having any gimmicks or extras that make them stand out from other carriers.

Beyond the state required bodily injury and property damage coverage, they offer medical, fire and theft, collision, roadside assistance, uninsured motorist, rental coverage, and manufacturer replacement part coverage.

Available Discounts

Much like everything else they do, Wawanesa’s list of discounts is clear and straightforward.

Unlike other companies, their list is not exceptionally unique or long.

They offer discounts for multi-car policies, mature drivers (drivers over 55 who complete a special “mature driver” course offered by the DMV), driver training, and loyalty.

However, if you are a good driver, you are already getting exceptionally low rates.

If you have additional items to insure, such as home or rental, you may find the premiums very competitive when applying discounts. 

Quotes compared by price for 55 y/o driver with Progressive, Wawanesa, State Farm, Farmers, and Grange. Note: For a 55 year old driver with a clean driving history you will find most any of the companies illustrated competitive. Wawanesa is able to offer the 3rd cheapest quotes with a price at $611 per year. Both Progressive and State Farm offer lower rates with prices at $598 and $610 respectfully. The only drawback is the limitation of California or Oregon. If you do move outside of either state you will have to drop their coverage.

Customer Reviews: Difficulty getting Help, but Fair Dealings

As stated earlier, Wawanesa stakes a lot on their reputation with their customers.

While there are negative customer reviews on many sites, many of them have resolutions in progress.

Most of the other negative reviews I found were centered around the difficulty of getting in contact with customer service agents.

Despite the negatives, when looking at several different review sites, there were very few complaints across the board regarding policies, issues with claims, estimations, or settlements.

This is a Positive Indicator

This means that, despite possible difficulty in contacting a service agent, you will likely be getting good treatment from a company that is not trying to undercut you in pay-outs.

Odds are, if you ever get into an accident, the company will treat you fairly.

Just be warned: if you are found at fault, your rates will likely see a significant jump.

Verdict: Who is Wawanesa Good For?

If you are a safe driver in Oregon or California with a clean record, Wawanesa will give you amazing rates and fair dealings so long as your record stays clean.

Their policies are straightforward and simple, so if you are looking for a long list of extra perks such as rideshare or mechanical coverage, you will have to shop with another company.

If you do not have a stellar driving record, you also may have better luck looking elsewhere.

However, if you meet their driver’s criteria, it will definitely be worth getting quotes from them. 






Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.