fbpx
Phone: 1-(855) 233-7818

What Every DUI Offender That Needs Car Insurance Should Know

Are you currently insured?
Yes No

Updated February 28th, 2021

Checked by
Jaime Arias
Licensed Agent
Reviewed by
Maurice Draine
Former P&C Agent

Car insurance does not have to be complicated, even if you have a recent DUI or DWI on your driving record.

You may be concerned about your rates increasing with your insurance company following a drunk driving infraction. Still, there are things you can do to find the cheapest car insurance after being convicted of a DUI.

Best Cheap Car Insurance After a DUI

Cheapest Car Insurance for a DUI - Quick Hits
AutoInsureSavings.orgThe cheapest DUI car insurance options are:

Cheapest in California: Mercury Insurance
Cheapest in New York: Progressive
Cheapest in Florida: State Farm
Cheapest in Texas: Texas Farm Bureau
Cheapest in Ohio: American Family
Cheapest in Georgia: State Farm
Cheapest in Pennsylvania: Erie Insurance
Cheapest in Illinois: Country Financial

-- Lowering your rates with a DUI conviction can be complicated but not impossible. The trick is never to let it happen again.

-- Insurance rates increase from 50 to 240% with a DUI, depending on your zip code and the insurance company.

-- Suppose you aren't obligated to full coverage with a car loan or lease. In that case, the best option is to lower your liability limits and drop collision and comprehensive coverage to save money.

Read on to learn about vital things you need to get car insurance for DUI offenders. 

Then ask the auto insurance experts at AutoInsureSavings for more information.

What Does a DUI on Your Record Mean for Insurance Providers?

A DUI mark on your DMV driving record can lead to an astronomical price increase in your car insurance costs, plus a loss of driving privileges. 

InsurerMonthly Cost Before DUIMonthly Cost After DUI
The General Insurance$93$151
Allstate$92$159
Direct Auto$84$167
Esurance$77$172
GEICO$82$180

If you get a driving under the influence charge, your car insurance provider may decide not to renew your policy.

In that case, you will need to find a new car insurance company. As a recent DUI offender, you will likely be considered a high-risk driver with possible driver’s license suspension or required ignition interlock device, leading to higher premiums.

CompanyStandard PremiumPremium with DUI% increase
Progressive$1,526$2,11128%
State Farm$1,472$2,09930%
Liberty Mutual$1,630$2,58337%
Farmers$1,538$2,63842%
USAA$1,044$1,83244%
Allstate$1,783$3,17444%
GEICO$1,290$2,48349%
The General Insurance$1,480$2,89951%
Nationwide$1,481$2,97551%

*USAA is for qualified military members, their spouses, and direct family members. Rates may vary depending on driver profiles.

Do You Need an SR-22 for Proof of Insurance After a DUI?

Yes, an SR-22 is required in many states following a DUI or DWI conviction. In Florida and Virginia, it’s an FR-44 form.

If the judge mandates you to have an SR-22, your auto insurance carrier will issue it to the DMV. The SR-22 is proof that you have met the state’s minimum financial responsibility requirements to drive a motor vehicle by having car insurance coverage in place.

You must maintain auto insurance coverage for the entire time required to have the SR-22, usually three to five years. The SR-22 form costs $30 to $50. 

Find Cheap Car Insurance Quotes by Zip Code for a DUI with AutoInsureSavings

DUI QUOTES

✔ Personalized quotes in less than 2 minutes

✔ No signup required

✔ 100% Free to Compare Quotes

How Much Does Car Insurance Increase After a DUI?

Depending on the state, you can expect to pay average rates of 50 to 240% more than your pre-DUI rates for first-time offenders with an auto insurance company.

Rate increases vary from carrier to carrier and state to state.

AutoInsureSavings.org licensed agents completed a study and found car insurance after a driving under the influence violation increased by $1,363 per year for full coverage and $588 annually for a minimum coverage insurance policy for a 30-year-old driver. 

Car insurance quotes depend on various factors such as your past driving history, marital status, credit score, zip code, type of coverage, and the insurance company you choose.

Most Expensive States to Get a DUI Conviction

North Carolina, Michigan, and Hawaii are the most expensive states to get drunk driving infractions.

In North Carolina, a driver with a DUI conviction in their driving history will pay $3,200 more per year. A driver in Michigan will pay $3,117 more per year, and a driver in Hawaii will pay $2,922 more per year for car insurance. 

Out of those three states, the biggest percentage car insurance increase for a DUI conviction is Hawaii, with an 80% increase in rates.

Other states you will see a big price increase in auto insurance quotes after DUI offenses are California, Kentucky, New Jersey, and Rhode Island. 

FULL COVERAGE CAR INSURANCE AFTER A DUI

StateFull coverage policy with clean driving historyFull coverage with one DUIAnnual difference
North Carolina$1,187$4,387$3,200
Michigan$2,522$5,639$3,117
Hawaii$1,209$4,131$2,922
California$1,700$3,847$2,147
Rhode Island$1,690$3,211$1,521
New Jersey$1,838$3,186$1,348
Kentucky$2,280$3,625$1,345
Connecticut$1,722$2,986$1,264
Louisiana$3,203$4,425$1,222
Arizona$1,476$2,599$1,123
Georgia$1,699$2,832$1,133
Vermont$1,011$2,111$1,100
Florida$2,411$3,486$1,075
Wisconsin$1,088$2,076$988
Massachusetts$1,342$2,280$938
South Dakota$1,327$2,257$930
Nevada$1,912$2,836$924
Wyoming$1,206$2,127$921
Minnesota$1,316$2,236$920
Alabama$1,472$2,370$898
District of Columbia$1,574$2,467$893
West Virginia$1,361$2,248$887
Delaware$1,572$2,453$881
New Hampshire$1,126$1,983$857
Arkansas$1,531$2,387$856
Kansas$1,407$2,239$835
Montana$1,326$2,158$832
North Dakota$1,241$2,064$823
Washington$1,326$2,146$820
Colorado$1,625$2,427$802
South Carolina$1,511$2,299$788
Oklahoma$1,627$2,407$780
Maryland$1,611$2,368$757
New York$2,127$2,874$747
Tennessee$1,254$2,028$774
Illinois$1,237$1,984$750
Texas$1,503$2,237$734
Mississippi$1,471$2,197$726
Alaska$1,239$1,965$726
Idaho$1,037$1,760$726
Iowa$1,021$1,743$722
New Mexico$1,329$2,045$716
Ohio$1,028$1,732$704
Missouri$1,435$2,054$619
Virginia$1,028$1,643$615
Indiana$1,028$1,639$611
Maine$986$1,587$601
Utah$1,327$1,914$587
Pennsylvania$1,320$1,900$580
Nebraska$1,265$1,784$519
Oregon$1,377$1,802$425

States With Cheapest Increase in DUI Insurance

States with the lowest rate hike for DUI car insurance are Oregon, Nebraska, and Pennsylvania.

In Oregon, you will see your auto insurance rates increase by $425 annually, Nebraska rates increase by $519 per year, and in Pennsylvania, insurance quotes increase by $580.

Out of those three states, the lowest percentage rate increase is Oregon at 24%

Other states where driving under the influence conviction has a low percentage rate increase are Indiana, Maine, and Utah. All three average $600 increase in annual car insurance rates or about 28%. 

Find Cheap Car Insurance Quotes by Zip Code for a DUI with AutoInsureSavings

DUI QUOTES

✔ Personalized quotes in less than 2 minutes

✔ No signup required

✔ 100% Free to Compare Quotes

Driving while impaired by alcohol or drugs is a severe problem in the US. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration reported an average of one alcohol-impaired-related fatality in the US every 50 minutes in 2016.

The CDC estimates alcohol-related car accidents cost more than $40 billion annually. These statistics show why car insurance increases following a DUI conviction.

Cheapest Car Insurance After a DUI

While your rates will likely increase following a driving while impaired charge, there are ways to find cheaper car insurance rates.

Comparing your options online will help you find the most affordable car insurance rates in your area.

You may be able to reduce your coverage limits if you typically carry full coverage.

Full coverage includes comprehensive and collision coverage and required if you lease your vehicle or have a car loan.

Increasing your deductible, say from $500 to $1,000, can also result in significant premium savings.

Changing your liability limits and your deductible shifts more of the financial responsibility of an accident to you, so be sure you understand the coverage limits you are selecting.

Cheapest DUI Insurance Rates in California

Drivers who have been convicted of a DUI in California can see the rates increase from 60 to 240% per year.

California’s best insurance company for DUI offenders is Mercury, which offered our agents a $2,790 quote for a 30-year-old with full coverage. Mercury’s rate is 28% cheaper than California’s average rates. 

California companyAnnual Cost Monthly Cost
Mercury$2,790$232
GEICO$2,943$245
State Farm$3,231$269
California average$3,847$320

In California, auto insurers aren’t allowed to use your credit score to determine your auto insurance rate. If you have a low credit score, your rates won’t increase in California.

Auto insurers cannot increase your coverage rates during the insurance policy in California. They can only raise rates at renewal.

If you get a drunken driving traffic violation in California, you shouldn’t see an increase in your auto insurance until the renewal of your policy.

Cheapest DUI Insurance Rates in New York

Progressive insurance company is your best insurance option in New York for DUI offenders. They offered us a quote at $2,286 per year, which is 21% lower than the $2,874 New York’s state average rates.

New York companyAnnual Cost Monthly Cost
Progressive$2,286$190
State Farm$2,474$206
New York Central Mutual$2,630$219
New York average$2,874$239

Cheapest DUI Insurance Rates in Florida

Our licensed insurance agents found State Farm ($2,570 per year) provides the lowest rates for people with a DUI in Florida. Their rate is 27% cheaper than the state average $3,486 Florida rate for drinking and driving offenders.

Florida companyAnnual Cost Monthly Cost
State Farm$2,570$214
Progressive$2,832$236
GEICO$3,033$252
Florida average$3,486$290

Driving while impaired offenses in Florida requires drivers to have the car insurance company file an FR-44 on their behalf to prove they have the required coverage limits.

FR-44 policies must be paid in full in Florida, making it essential to comparison shop after a DUI conviction to get the best coverage rates.

Cheapest DUI Insurance Rates in Texas

Texas’s average rate is $2,237 per year, and the most affordable option for drivers with a recent violation is Texas Farm Bureau with a $1,754 quote per year for a 30-year-old driver.

Texas companyAnnual Cost Monthly Cost
Texas Farm Bureau$1,754$146
GEICO$1,841$153
Progressive$1,955$162
Texas average$2,237$186

Cheapest Rates After a DUI in Ohio

Ohio drivers can find the most affordable DUI coverage with American Family, who provided our agents a $1,373 quote for our sample 30-year-old driver.

American Family’s rate is 21% cheaper than the Ohio mean rate of $1,732 for driving while impaired offenders. 

Ohio companyAnnual Cost Monthly Cost
American Family$1,373$114
State Farm$1,490$124
USAA$1,515$116
Ohio average$1,732$144

Cheapest Rates After a DUI in Georgia

State Farm provides the least expensive quotes for DUI offenders in Georgia, with $1,688 annual rates for a 30-year-old driver, or $1,144 lower than the state average $2,832 rate.

Georgia DUI’s stay on your driving record for a decade, another reason to make sure to comparison shop for cheaper auto insurance quotes.  

Georgia companyAnnual Cost Monthly Cost
State Farm$1,688$140
Allstate$1,930$160
Country Financial$2,238$186
Georgia average$2,832$236

Cheapest Rates After a DUI in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania residents with a recent DUI conviction should compare quotes with Erie Insurance. Erie provided our agents a $1,601 rate per year or 16% cheaper than the $1,900 average Pennsylvania rate.

Pennsylvania companyAnnual Cost Monthly Cost
Erie$1,601$133
State Farm$1,678$139
Allstate$1,955$162
Pennsylvania average$1,900$236

Cheapest Rates After a DUI in Illinois

If you get caught drinking and driving in Illinois, your insurance rates will go up 38% on average to $1,984.

With Country Financial, you get car insurance in Illinois at $1,590 per year or only a 20% increase in your insurance premium.

Illinois companyAnnual Cost Monthly Cost
Country Financial$1,590$132
Progressive$1,727$143
GEICO$1,905$158
Illinois average$1,984$165

Cheapest Full Coverage Insurance Rates After DUI Offenses

You may not want to lower your coverage to save money on premium costs with your car insurance company in some cases. 

If your vehicle is leased or has a lienholder, you may be obligated to carry specific auto insurance limits with a DWI conviction. 

If you are in this position and need to maintain full coverage following a conviction, you could consider lowering your liability coverage while raising your deductible limits on collision and comprehensive insurance.

Find Cheap Car Insurance Quotes by Zip Code for a DUI with AutoInsureSavings

DUI QUOTES

✔ Personalized quotes in less than 2 minutes

✔ No signup required

✔ 100% Free to Compare Quotes

You will take on more risk, so make sure to consult with your auto insurance company or licensed agent before lowering coverage limits.

And it is even more important to compare rates and continue shopping around for better rates at your renewals after a DUI/DWI charge. 

Cheapest Minimum Coverage Car Insurance After a DUI

If you have some flexibility on your coverage limits, you may be able to lower your coverage with your car insurance company to state minimum limits to save money each month on premiums.

Knowing a drunken driving charge will increase your rates, it may be more economical to drop coverage as low as you can afford to go.

During AutoInsureSavings.org analysis, for a driver with one DUI, the minimum required car insurance costs $97 a month, or about $45 more than someone with a clean driving history would pay.

AFFORDABLE MINIMUM COVERAGE INSURANCE FOR A DUI BY STATE

In Washington D.C., AutoInsureSavings.org licensed agents found Progressive is the cheapest auto insurance option for DUI offenders requiring minimum coverage.

Progressive provided us a quote at $1,824 per year or 31% lower than Washington D.C.’s average rate of $2,389. 

StateLowest DUI PremiumStateLowest DUI Premium
AlaskaState FarmMontanaLiberty Mutual
AlabamaProgressiveNorth CarolinaNorth Carolina Farm Bureau
ArkansasSouthern Farm Bureau CasualtyNorth DakotaFarmers
ArizonaState FarmNebraskaFarmers Mutual of Nebraska
CaliforniaMercuryNew HampshireConcord Group
ColoradoAllstateNew JerseyNew Jersey Manufacturers
ConnecticutState FarmNew MexicoProgressive
DelawareState FarmNevadaState Farm
FloridaAllstateNew YorkProgressive
GeorgiaProgressiveOhioAmerican Family
HawaiiState FarmOklahomaFarmers
IowaGEICOOregonAllstate
IdahoState FarmPennsylvaniaErie
IllinoisCountry FinancialRhode IslandTravelers
IndianaProgressiveSouth CarolinaState Farm
KansasAmerican FamilySouth DakotaState Farm
KentuckyKentucky Farm BureauTennesseeGEICO
LouisianaSouthern Farm BureauTexasTexas Farm Bureau
MassachusettsGEICOUtahBear River
MarylandErieVirginiaProgressive
MaineState FarmVermontState Farm
MichiganProgressiveWashingtonState Farm
MinnesotaProgressiveWisconsinProgressive
MissouriAmerican FamilyWest VirginiaState Farm
MississippiAlfaWyomingState Farm

Cheapest Car Insurance After a DUI by State

The auto insurance company you have before driving under the influence offense may not be the cheapest one afterward. 

In our licensed agent’s analysis, the cheapest car insurance company for drivers with a clean driving record could end being the most expensive insurance after a DUI traffic violation. Below are statistics. 

Importance to Comparison Shop After a DUI

Allstate is one of the cheapest insurers in Michigan for clean record drivers but one of the most expensive auto insurance companies for drivers with a DUI.

In New Jersey, Travelers Insurance is a better option for those without drunk driving infractions but one of the most expensive auto insurers for drivers with a DUI in New Jersey.

Find Cheap Car Insurance Quotes by Zip Code for a DUI with AutoInsureSavings

DUI QUOTES

✔ Personalized quotes in less than 2 minutes

✔ No signup required

✔ 100% Free to Compare Quotes

In Virginia, Nationwide Insurance is a cheaper insurance option for most drivers with good driving history. Still, it is one of the most expensive insurance companies for DUI offenders in Virginia.

Liberty Mutual offers the best insurance coverage in Washington State for good drivers. Still, it becomes one of the most expensive insurance companies for drivers with a DUI conviction in Washington.

— If you are a military member or a family member of service personnel in Arizona, you get the cheapest rates with USAA. However, if you get a DWI traffic violation, you will have the most expensive insurance rates in Arizona with USAA.

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies for a DUI

Some car insurance companies specialize in high-risk drivers, so choosing one of those companies may be the cheapest option following a driving under the influence charge.

For example, Progressive advertises their coverage for drivers following DWI charges only increases by 13% for the first offense. Their rates may be a good starting point to compare car insurance carriers and coverages.

AFFORDABLE INSURANCE RATES BY COMPANY WITH DUI

CompanyAverage rate for full coverage with a DUIAverage rate for minimum coverage with a DUI
American Family$1,432$688
Erie$1,465$580
New Jersey Manufacturers (NJM)$1,576$712
Country Financial$1,688$616
USAA*$1,732$687
Safeco$2,003$716
The Hartford$2,143$783
Travelers$2,276$986
Progressive$2,280$801
State Farm$2,365$975
National General$2,437$876
Geico$2,511$1,031
Mercury$2,682$1,044
Auto-Owners$2,921$1,053
Farmers$2,954$1,316
Nationwide$3,050$1,376
Auto Club of Southern California$3,067$1,400
Allstate$3,236$1,443
Kemper$3,311$1,328
Amica$3,583$1,275
MetLife$3,900$1,549
Liberty Mutual$3,951$1,972
CSAA$4,126$1,461
21st Century$4,328$1,876
The Hanover$4,417$2,041
Automobile Club Group$4,943$2,454

*USAA is for qualified military members, their spouses, and direct family members. Rates may vary depending on driver profiles.

How to Shop for the Cheapest Car Insurance After a DUI

One important trick to remember after getting a DUI is that you should shop around – you do not need to accept the first car insurance rate you find.

Your current insurance company may drop you, but if not, their rate may not be the most competitive for your new situation. By comparing rates and coverages, you will find the most competitive carrier for your needs.

Going online and using an online calculator or quote tool is a quick and efficient way to shop for the cheapest car insurance after DUI offenses. Remember to shop around at renewal time, as well – you may be eligible for a better rate after six or twelve months of good driving.

How can I Lower my Car Insurance After a DUI?

Shopping around is one way to lower car insurance rates after a DUI. Another way to lower your rates is to reduce your coverages. If you carry high limits, you may reduce your coverage limits or increase your deductible to lower your monthly auto insurance premium.

Be sure to ask for any discounts that apply to you. Many carriers offer discounts for things like bundling your auto and home insurance policies, selecting paperless invoices and automatic payments, and sharing telematics data.

Because many carriers use your credit score as a rating factor, be sure to maintain good credit following your offense. DUI charges are expensive, so thinking ahead about ensuring your credit score stays high as you pay for the charge is a smart strategy.

Do not incur any additional tickets, charges, or driver’s license suspensions. Be a safe, courteous driver and avoid further infractions on your license.

Incurring additional moving violations or loss of driving privileges following a DUI charge could result in higher premiums or your policy termination with your insurance company and possibly jail time. 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is DUI Insurance?

Some car insurance carriers will write coverage for drivers who have DUI convictions, and others will not. Sometimes the policies written by carriers for drivers with the charges are called ‘DUI policies’ even though they are standard auto insurance policies written for high-risk drivers. The car insurance policy itself will be the same as others written by that carrier.

How Does a DUI Affect Your Insurance Rates?

A DUI charge will increase your auto insurance rates and affect your premium for several years following the initial charge. Each carrier differs, and rates vary from driver to driver and state to state. Because there are so many different rating factors that affect your premium, it is good to shop around and compare rates following a DUI.

What is the Difference Between a DUI and DWI?

A DWI charge is a Driving While Intoxicated – or Driving While Impaired – charge, while DUI means Driving Under the Influence of prescription drugs or alcohol. In some states, the terms are used interchangeably. In others, different blood alcohol levels determine the severity of the charge.

Some states also consider DWAI charges – Driving While Ability Impaired – for drivers who do not meet BAC limits for higher charges but who are still impaired while behind the wheel. A BAC of .08 or higher is a DWI charge in many states, and a BAC of .05 and above is a DWAI charge.

How Long Does a DUI Stay on Your Driving Record?

A DUI can affect your car insurance rates for five to seven years. It will stay on your driving record for three to five years in some states. In California, a DUI stays on your driving record for 10 years.

How can I get the Cheapest DUI Insurance?

Some carriers specialize in high-risk drivers and therefore can offer more competitive rates. The General and Safe Auto are two examples. 

It is worth your time to shop around to find the best carrier for your situation following a DUI offense. Remember to compare rates often – at least at each renewal – so you can be confident you continue to have the best rate following a DUI.

How to Learn More

After a DUI offense, contact our auto insurance experts at AutoInsureSavings. Our licensed professionals will be happy to answer any questions you have.

Methodology

AutoInsureSavings.org licensed insurance agents used average DUI rates for ten zip codes from Quadrant Information Services in each state from 5 carriers with full coverage and a $500 deductible. We applied standard discounts such as paperless billing, multi-policy, and home insurance.

For minimum coverage, we adjusted the numbers above to reflect state laws.

Our sample 30-year-old driver drives a 2018 Honda Accord with 12,000 annual miles.
Sources

Insurance Information Institute. “Facts + Statistics: Alcohol-impaired driving.”
Progressive. “Auto insurance after a DUI.”
GEICO. “SR-22 Vehicle Insurance.”
State Farm. “What is High-Risk Auto Insurance.”
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). “Drunk Driving.”
Center for Disease Control (CDC.gov). “Impaired Driving.”

Maurice Draine

Maurice Draine

Maurice, a former licensed P&C insurance agent with a 4-year degree in journalism. He resides in Minneapolis and has worked as a technical writer for UnitedHealthcare and Wells Fargo, where he created Medicare-related policies and procedures for three years. He is also an editor for AutoInsureSavings.org.

Comments are closed.

Follow us on:
© 2021 AutoInsureSavings LLC. All Rights Reserved. Use of AutoInsureSavings LLC Services (DBA AutoInsureSavings.org) is subject to our Terms of Service, Privacy Policy and License #3000705723. CCPA Disclaimer DUNS: 117443053

Advertiser Disclosure: All rates, insurance quotes, products and services are presented without warranty and guarantee. When evaluating insurance rates, verify directly with your current provider or insurance agent. Insurance quotes and offers are not binding, nor a guarantee of car insurance coverage. Some of the offers within the content are from companies where AutoInsureSavings.org may receive compensation. This does not influence our analysis of services or products. Our opinions are our own in good faith. We are an objective third-party resource for everything auto insurance.